3 ms·
If the choice is "The Apple Watch heart monitor sends too many people to the doctor" and "The Apple Watch heart monitor sends too few people to the doctor," I'm
by reaperducer 6y ago
If the choice is "The Apple Watch heart monitor sends too many people to the doctor" and "The Apple Watch heart monitor sends too few people to the doctor," I'm OK with this.
- ihattendorf 6y agoI agree, but obviously it depends on how many people is "too many". From the article it looks like 10% of those who went to the doctor were diagnosed with a cardiac condition, but what if it was 1%? A 90% false positive rate is already fairly high.
- henriquez 6y agoMaybe it’s just more common to have heart “anomalies” than people think. Historically it’s never been common for people having heart monitors strapped to them all the time, so now we’re In uncharted territory. Maybe there’s some scientific learning we still have to do about how the heart works, and what is considered “in spec.”
- cratermoon 6y agoIt is common! I know as a heart patient I once wore a Holter monitor (https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/holter-monitor/about/pac-20385039 https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/holter-monitor/a...) and in the process learned that your heartbeat isn't perfect. Pre-beats are pretty common and completely harmless.
- closetohome 6y agoAnother way of looking at it is that 1 in 10 people who were alerted to a potential health issue ended up needing medical assistance. That's actually pretty good for a basic non-medical screening.
- acdha 6y agoThat's true with a big caveat: how many of those people get invasive treatments for things which would not have actually become problems? They've backed away from screening as aggressively for certain cancers because the risks of aggressive treatment turned out to be significant and it turned out that more people than expected had tumors which didn't develop into a problem before they died of something else. I don't know how plausible that is with heart issues — maybe aggressive prescription of something like statins with significant side-effects? — but it's very important to consider the cost of false-positives.
- ebg13 6y ago> how many of those people get invasive treatments for things which would not have actually become problems? That's really the doctor's issue to address, not the device's. Sticking your head in the sand isn't the right solution to the problems of dealing with information too aggressively. > They've backed away from screening as aggressively for certain cancers because the risks of aggressive treatment turned out to be significant and it turned out that more people than expected had tumors which didn't develop into a problem before they died of something else. Literally the only way to build viable metrics for which tumors will develop into problems is for _everyone_ get screened, not for no one to get screened. The problem of treating too aggressively is a treatment problem, not a measurement problem. If we avoid measuring, we have no way to learn how to treat better. If we decide to never look because we don't yet know how to handle the information, then we will never know how to handle the information.
- DanBC 6y ago> The problem of treating too aggressively is a treatment problem, not a measurement problem. One of the most important questions you can ask your doctor is "what happens if I don't have this test?" and "What happens if I don't have this treatment?" But most people don't ask these questions. And so it really is a measurement problem. Over-testing, over-diagnosis, and over-treatment are well understood mechanisms of harm. https://ebm.bmj.com/content/23/1/1 https://ebm.bmj.com/content/23/1/1 https://www.bmj.com/content/362/bmj.k2820 https://www.bmj.com/content/362/bmj.k2820 The harm caused by inappropriate screening is so severe that we (UK) have a committee to weigh up the harm vs benefit of different screening programmes. https://www.gov.uk/government/groups/uk-national-screening-committee-uk-nsc https://www.gov.uk/government/groups/uk-national-screening-c...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Clent 6y agoIt's not clear from the article if it actually sent anyone to the doctor or if they simply brought it up during an normal visit.