8 ms·
I’ve seen similar comments come up and have been trying to understand if there’s something specific to Palantir, or just data analysis in general. From my limi
by prepend 6y ago
I’ve seen similar comments come up and have been trying to understand if there’s something specific to Palantir, or just data analysis in general.
From my limited analysis and use of Palantir, it’s just a data management and analysis stack like so many others (SAS, SAP, alteryx, RStudio, etc) and similar to stuff that AWS, Azure, Google, IBM, Oracle offer as well. In that it’s just a giant bucket of data with ways to link it and connect it.
Is there something special about how Palantir does it that makes it better at analyzing data and thus more of a threat?
What’s weird about using it is that it just seems to be a specific way (like so many others) of just scaling up what I’ve seen for decades of making big databases and using them.
- trowaway888 6y agoThis is my understanding as well, which is why I was hoping someone on HN might be able to clarify OP's claim it's threat to liberty. Instead I am being downvoted. Is there no room for genuine curiosity on HN?
- glenda 6y agoI think what’s specific to Palantir is their insistence on working with only organizations like DHS and law enforcement. Intelligence data fusion centers are used to compile data from various agencies and they’re stocked with tools like Palantir and Dataminr but IBM, Microsoft and all the usual players also offer fusion center data management products which I would consider to be just as harmful.
- trowaway888 6y agoI think that statement is inaccurate. They do not work with only organizations like DHS and law enforcement. In general, I think roughly 40-60% of their work is with what you described and the rest is commercial entities. I imagine many vendors service organizations like DHS and law enforcement. Are they all threats to liberty? In concrete terms, what is the threat, or why are they a threat to liberty?
- glenda 6y agoThey are a threat to liberty because they are used to perform surveillance and intelligence gathering on American citizens. Before the Snowden revelation this kind of behavior would have been considered criminal.
- prepend 6y agoIs that Palantir or the analysts that use it? I think what confuses me is I still don’t understand your argument. Is Excel a threat to liberty because it is also used massively to perform surveillance? Palantir is a software company with professional services. I’m not sure if you think they are a threat because you don’t understand what they do. Or because you think all software companies that do this work are a threat? Or because you think Palantir is so much better than Microsoft and IBM and all their competitors? Or something else.
- trowaway888 6y agoEverything that is publicly available states that Palantir does not do surveillance or intelligence gathering...Or data collecting, gathering or mining. I have not used the platforms, but others here seem to validate that. Do you have any sources of this claim? It would be helpful and valuable for framing my perspective and the discussion at large.
- dx87 6y agoOutside of SV, working with law enforcement and government agencies isn't viewed as a cardinal sin. I wouldn't claim they're a threat to liberty just because you don't like them.
- glenda 6y agoIntelligence operations against your own citizens is a serious reason to have an issue with those organizations. It’s not just a personal preference.
- prepend 6y ago> working with only organizations like DHS and law enforcement. Is this true? I thought they work with all industries and they seem to have a big financial and healthcare practice. Wikipedia [0] calls out major companies such as Morgan Stanley, Merck KGaA, Airbus, and Fiat Chrysler Automobiles NV. And those aren’t part of homeland security. Some random report I found online [1] lists their closest competitors as Cognizant, Infosys, Cerner, and Wipro. That are just big analytics consulting groups and an EHR vendor. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palantir_Technologies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palantir_Technologies [1] https://incfact.com/company/palantirtechnologies-paloalto-ca/ https://incfact.com/company/palantirtechnologies-paloalto-ca...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- javert 6y agoPalantir is a critical component of the "homeland security apparatus" which employs enormous amounts of Americans (especially in N. Virginia) and is becoming a powerful political constituency unto itself. This constituency has and will push for government expansion of surveillance, counterintelligence, the military, and domestic policing in order to enrich its constituent corporations and government bureaus and their employees. This is the livelihood of hundreds of thousands of Americans. I hope there are enough terrorists out there, and criminals in here, to justify that expenditure...... You might as well consider N. Virginia and its "colonies" in other parts of the country (e.g. aerospace around Los Angeles) as an extra super-powerful but hidden state within the state. Or you can view it as another branch of government. This hidden state is not partisan. It does not care which political party is in power. Both political parties kowtow to it. I would highly suggest investing in stocks of affiliated companies (Palantir, Oracle, defense stocks, ATT, Verizon) as they aren't going anywhere - ever.
- prepend 6y agoI think that’s true, but also true for the other companies I mentioned. Is Palantir more of a part of the apparatus than SAS? I think it’s less so than dedicated military industrial firms like Lockheed Martin or Northrup Grumman and whatnot. If anything, going public will more clearly show what percentage of revenue comes from government vs non-government.
- javert 6y agoI believe Palantir exists specifically to serve the government surveillance "industry." Do you have information showing otherwise?
- PopsiclePete 6y agoAll that's happening with or without Palantir. We have Big Data, we have data scientists, we have ML/AI....it's going to be used for all of these goals no matter what. The genie is out of the bottle. Blaming Palantir here is a bit like blaming Colt or Smith & Wesson. They're just one of many companies that are providing, or could be providing, or with they were providing, these same services. And the services themselves, and the science behind them aren't inherently evil. It's not like the math behind their models is special "let's oppress society" math. Blaming Palantir for the things the government is doing is as effective as blaming Boeing or Google - whose services are also used by the US Government for various (nefarious) purposes.