7 ms·
> Aboriginal people just commit more crime. That isn't racist. Er... that sounds incredibly racist?
by justinclift 6y ago
> Aboriginal people just commit more crime. That isn't racist.
Er... that sounds incredibly racist?
- dkdbejwi383 6y agoI think was the OP was saying is that indigenous people are more likely to commit crimes because of the circumstances that are put upon them by the system, and that they also lack access to better legal representation for the same reason, and are therefore more likely to be convicted of crimes. Really, it's due to economic circumstance (I bet poor white people are convicted of more crimes than rich white people). It just so happens that the system makes it very difficult for indigenous people to move up the economic ladder. The system is set up in such a way that it assumes indigenous people want to and/or should confirm to white European ideas of what is "normal" as well.
- morelisp 6y ago> circumstances that are put upon them by the system, and that they also lack access to better legal representation for the same reason, and are therefore more likely to be convicted of crimes. If only we had a convenient word for this, "the confluence of negative formal and material circumstances put upon someone because of race"...
- doctor_eval 6y agoI'd like to think that's what the OP was saying, but that's not remotely what the OP actually said. Also, they called me a moron, which (accurate or not) is not cool. > The system is set up in such a way that it assumes indigenous people want to and/or should confirm to white European ideas of what is "normal" as well I suspect that the system does not assume that aboriginal people want or should be European; rather, it doesn't think about aboriginal people at all.
- nobody9999 6y ago>Really, it's due to economic circumstance (I bet poor white people are convicted of more crimes than rich white people). Absolutely. Not that it's anything new. Nor is it limited to ethnic minorities. Consider Anatole France's observation[0]: "The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal bread." [0] https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Anatole_France https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Anatole_France
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Udik 6y agoIt's a fact. How can a fact be racist?
- doctor_eval 6y agoFacts taken out of context can obviously be racist. > Aboriginal people just commit more crime More crime than who? More crime than "Normal" people? Or, More crime than all other groups with the same economic opportunieis? More crime than groups with the same health issues? More crime than other people who go blind from trachoma and trichiasis despite it no longer being a public health problem in any other developed country in the world? [0] More crime than other people who have had their children systematically stolen? More crime than other people who have been racially abused in public, while playing a game of football? I mean, come on, you're a smart cookie. You can't accept a claim that "aboriginal people commit more crime" unless you compare it to some equivalent group. Aboriginal and non-aboriginal people are not remotely equivalent, because aboriginal people have been systematically denied the freedom, health outcomes and economic opportunities available to almost any other group in Australia. [0] https://healthinfonet.ecu.edu.au/learn/health-topics/eye-health/#aihref3 https://healthinfonet.ecu.edu.au/learn/health-topics/eye-hea...
- Udik 6y ago> Facts taken out of context can obviously be racist. A fact is a statement about reality. It can induce racism, but cannot be racist in itself. Facts are scientific, and science is not political. > More crime than who? Of non-Aboriginal people. > Or, More crime than all other groups with the same economic opportunities? Maybe or maybe not. That is beside the point. If you compare incarceration rates of Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people you have already decided that that is the division of the population you want to reason about. You cannot argue that the reason group A has higher incarceration rates of group B is because of racism, and when someone else proposes crime rates as an explanation, suddenly you switch to different population subdivisions: by economic opportunities, by health issues, etc. The question about incarceration is: are Aboriginals more likely to be incarcerated for the same crimes than non-Aboriginals?
- 188201 6y agoI find it really illogical to say some statement is racist because it lay out tendency of certain race having certain weakness. Racist is a race discrimination. Race discrimination is when you are treated differently because of your race. https://equalityhumanrights.com/en/advice-and-guidance/race-discrimination https://equalityhumanrights.com/en/advice-and-guidance/race-... Skin color is not the reason of a certain person to have certain ability, or certain moral standard. "Aboriginal people just commit more crime." is a factual statement about how many aboriginal people committing crime. It could be true or false. If the statement is "Aboriginal people just commit more crime, because they are aboriginal", then it is racist because it draws a causal relationship of race and crime rate which is completely false. Nowadays, from a statement of "Aboriginal people just commit more crime.", someone can see through the proposer's mind to assume he has stereotype impression on aboriginal people and inside his/her mind, the proposer thinks because of people's skin color, they will just magically commit more crime. So, it is concluded that the proposer is racist. This is thought crime, and law should assume people is innocent until proven in case of criminal law. It is really bad, because it does not let people to lay out the data based on race, and therefore cannot solve the real problem behind it. Why a specific race would commit more crime in a country? There must be a reason behind it. Maybe only one community with majority of a specific race committing most of the crime, and other communities of that race are completely normal. Then you have to further find the reason why that community committing so many crime etc. However, the left in America does not think like that. They just get a aggregate data of the country and lay out many disadvantage of certain race facing, and so it can justify minority group to victimize themselves. A term systematic racism is coined. If there is no equal outcome for each race then the society is racist. No active actors of racist is involved. The system itself is designed which cause non equal outcome among races and therefore must be overthrown and replaced with a non racist system. The whole idea is just giving up thinking analytically about the root cause of non equal outcome and blame it all to the society. If there is not enough educational resource because the state is consist of mainly poor blacks, then just let the rich state to subsidize the poor state. Rejecting better grade non-black is just solving the problem by a racist measure which is not moral. And it is also racist against the black because it implied black are just dumber, and I find it strange for black to accept that. No, because they are poor and does not have enough educational resource. I think the America left is so irrational that it starts to be very similar to Soviet Union style of thinking. PS: Not-White. Just a observation from other race outside America.