3 ms·
> Nothing will be more educational than a "GPL death sentence" to some multi-billion dollar multinational like Broadcom. I don't think you understand. That's
by m463 6y ago
> Nothing will be more educational than a "GPL death sentence" to some multi-billion dollar multinational like Broadcom.
I don't think you understand.
That's the equivalent of someone asking about relationship advice on the internet and getting all this "dump her" / "dump him" advice when really what's needed is a little more communication.
I would say a majority of the work in open software comes various forms of corporate sponsorship via sort of unofficial work from their employees.
You ask for "GPL death sentence" and you'll end up with a lot more Apple Computer employees who are for all practical purposes unable to work on any GPL projects.
Everything will be MIT and sharing changes will be withheld for the tiniest of reasons.
There are already plenty of reasons to shy away no matter how good it is for everyone.
Destroy your enemies by making them your friends.
- saagarjha 6y agoHow many Apple Computer employees work on GPL projects? I suspect that number is extremely low.
- the_mitsuhiko 6y agoPretty sure they are not allowed, so 0.
- m463 6y ago(right, that's what I was saying... Apple stays away from GPL and keeps their employees away from it too)
- baybal2 6y agoAgain, this it's not like it's a tragedy, it's an opposite. Opensource will very much benefit from less freeloader companies like Apple, and less companies of lesser rectitude hanging around OSS projects. Apples is free to go back 20 years, and copy *BSD userspace instead of GNU, which it used for 15 out of 20 years. They are completely free to chose Microsoft Trident instead kHTML for the browser engine. The are completely free to do the same for hundreds of other GPL libs they used in their commercial products. They are 100% free to do that... If they can pull it out. The thing is they chose it, because they couldn't make anything else work. Apples militantly opposes GPL, is a freeloader, was actively working around GPL legal language, and it uses DRM, and they are rumoured to be behind much of anti-GPL publicity campaigns. No, they are not good players at all, and will never be.
- the_mitsuhiko 6y ago> Again, this it's not like it's a tragedy, it's an opposite. Opensource will very much benefit from less freeloader companies like Apple, and less companies of lesser rectitude hanging around OSS projects. Is that so? Which examples do you have where Apple freeloads some GPL software? As far as I can tell Apple stopped adopting any GPL-3 code and effectively has stopped updating GPL-2 dependencies. They are in the process of completely removing it. On the other hand Apple still contributes actively to a lot of non GPL licensed Open Source code including LLVM.
- baybal2 6y agoIt is not like they were enthusiastic supporters of GPLv2 software either. I defeated your argument Mitsuhiko.