3 ms·
> Let's do you another favor: Let's further assume you limit yourself to books from the last, say, 250 years. Nothing before 1761. That's the wrong way to go!!
by bambax 16y ago
> Let's do you another favor: Let's further assume you limit yourself to books from the last, say, 250 years. Nothing before 1761.
That's the wrong way to go!! Start with Aristotle, rather, and read only books that have stood the test of time. What would be the point of reading every Kindle "space opera" priced at $0.99?
If you read all of Plutarch, Shakespeare, Montaigne, and Cervantès, you're fine, really.
- xyzzyz 16y agoI read some books of them and did not like them. I am not so much into reading great books as I am into reading books I like. Wasting many hours of my precious time reading books I do not enjoy only to feel smug does not sound like a particularly good idea for me.
- bambax 16y agoThe authors I mentioned are thoroughly enjoyable, they're not Kant or Hegel... Also, in order to know whether you like something or not you have to experience it. You may not like reading (as opposed to watching movies for example), but if you do enjoy reading you cannot not like Plutarch for example?
- xyzzyz 16y agoThe thing is, you may enjoy it, but I not so much. I read Shakespeare and Montaigne and they had not impress me as much as some recent hard s-f did. I really like reading books and I see that Dostojewski's, or Hemingway's, or Kafka's etc books are really good, because I have read enough books in my life to be able to distinguish good writers from bad ones to a certain degree, nevertheless reading their books does not give me as much pleasure as reading hard s-f sometimes does, and this is the reason I read books at all -- to feel good. Some people may (and surely do) take pleasure in deconstructing classical writers to pieces, or learning from them what was the zeitgeist back then, or finding hidden senses, but all these things are not for me. That's why I don't think that "you should read authors XXX and YYY, because it is good for the development of your literary taste" is a wise thing to say -- it surely may be, but this may not be the point of reading.
- bambax 16y ago> "you should read authors XXX and YYY, because it is good for the development of your literary taste" I'm not sure "literary taste" matters much (except for certain professions: (English) teachers and writers mainly), but you yourself seem to be quite happy to have developed one: _I have read enough books in my life to be able to distinguish good writers from bad ones_. But I don't agree that the point of reading is to "feel good". There are many ways to "feel good" and if I had to list them, I'm not sure reading would make the top ten — I'm positive it wouldn't make the top five. To me, the point of reading is to learn something: either something about the world or something about human nature. Therefore, a good book is a book that contains _new_, genuine information; and that's why I think that starting with the classics is a good idea. "Classics" are where new information was first created, and that's why they became classics.
- roel_v 16y agoThis comment is the exact embodiment of what the article calls the 'culling', and which it advocates is the wrong way to approach the issue. Plus, he wasn't saying one should actually skip those books, he was just making the point of how many books there are, and how few of them one can read, even with a lot of devotion.
- bambax 16y ago"he"'s a she: name's Linda. The point I am making is that it doesn't matter "how many books there are", it only matters how many GOOD books there are. I think a way to know which books are good before you've read them, is to rely on the "wisdom of the ages"; you may have a better approach (your friends tastes, Amazon recommendations, whatever) but it doesn't change the fact that most books are not worth reading and one should only strive to read the books that are.
- billybob 16y agoAlthough I would agree that "most books are not worth reading," some might disagree. But the fact remains that one has very limited time. So a more universal way to put it would be "you have to prioritize somehow." Ratings and "classic" status are two possible ways.
- billybob 16y agoC.S. Lewis had an interesting argument for why one should read old books: "Every age has its own outlook. It is specially good at seeing certain truths and specially liable to make certain mistakes. We all, therefore, need the books that will correct the characteristic mistakes of our own period. And that means the old books. [snip] Not, of course, that there is any magic about the past. People were no cleverer then than they are now; they made as many mistakes as we. But not the same mistakes. They will not flatter us in the errors we are already committing; and their own errors, being now open and palpable, will not endanger us. [snip] To be sure, the books of the future would be just as good a corrective as the books of the past, but unfortunately we cannot get at them."