2 ms·
I'll join the crowd and say, if this doesn't use real money, it's essentially worthless. Even if people value a "reputation" the way they want HN or Reddit kar
by crazygringo 6y ago
I'll join the crowd and say, if this doesn't use real money, it's essentially worthless.
Even if people value a "reputation" the way they want HN or Reddit karma... people's behavior is ultimately extremely different. They make wilder bets "just for fun", because the rewards are highly asymmetrical: everybody cares if you're top of the leaderboard, nobody cares if you're in the bottom 95%, so the rational strategy is to make wild improbable bets and hope you get lucky, because there's lots of upside if you win and zero downside if you don't. (Or create 1,000+ different accounts to cover every combination of outcomes, and only publicly claim ownership of the one that wins the most.) All of this necessarily "pollutes" predictions making them ultimately worthless.
Prediction markets have to use real money people care about not losing. There is simply no way around that principle.
Poker players are well aware of this: advice on learning poker stresses how important it is to play for money as opposed to "fake money", because you and the other players will all play differently. (Play money is only when you're learning/practicing the basic mechanics of the game.)
Now of course, prediction markets have the unfortunate necessary side effect of people making money off of morally abhorrent events -- literally profiting off of a genocide or terrorist bombing -- when they successfully predict them. And a lot of people also see it as closer to gambling than investing. Which is why I can't ever imagine a large corporation like Facebook designing one -- it would be suicidal PR.
- carlosf 6y agoOnly trust those with skin in the game, definitely a principle to live by.
- basch 6y agoIt's an interesting way to observe who falls into what reality.
- dynamite-ready 6y agoThere's another discussion a similar kind above, but I think the Open Source community, Twitter, this place, Reddit, and even the likes of 4Chan, have proven that very able people will happily make exceptional contributions to various areas of knowledge, for a seemingly intangible incentive. What's more, with Facebook attached, this will probably be the most prominent predication market yet known... Tbh, it would have been more on brand for Twitter to do this, but it's still very cool. I think the volume and kudos associated with the scale the brand name will bring, will make this one of the more successful products of it's type, in terms of results.
- crazygringo 6y agoOh I'm not disputing that people will contribute at all, in fact I'm positively sure they will. The issue is that people's contributions will be highly skewed, for the reasons I listed. Here's an analogy: imagine someone starts a separate stock market with play money, but asks everyone to invest "as if they would with real money". Do you really think that stock market will track the real stock market, even remotely? Of course not. It'll be full of wild swings, people will make decisions for entertainment, nobody will pay attention to market fundamentals, because nothing is tethering it to reality. A prediction market without real money suffers from the exact same problem. I don't think open source or internet forums are a valuable analogy here, unfortunately -- pull requests are accepted or rejected by a maintainer, Wikipedia has very strict rules on what is accepted, and misinformation on Twitter and Reddit is rampant. A prediction market attempts to provide actual objective predictions without anyone in charge, which makes it totally different.