3 ms·
> First, it was intended to serve a half-slave-owning society. Semantics. The point is that it was intended to serve a society which no longer exists. The soc
by krapp 6y ago
> First, it was intended to serve a half-slave-owning society.
Semantics. The point is that it was intended to serve a society which no longer exists.
The society that is currently American society is not the same in scale, scope, complexity, culture or tenor to American society in the 18th century. It's the same only in the way the Ship of Theseus is the same after having been gradually transformed from a small boat to a modern aircraft carrier, which is to say, fundamentally different in every way that matters.
>Second: When do we begin to consider that? Maybe in 1868, when the 14th Amendment was ratified?
How about now?
The Electoral College had one job - to prevent a demagogue like Trump from taking power. He was elected by a fraction of a fraction of the populace, and a minority of those who voted, thanks in no small part to a system in which only a few votes in one or two swing states actually ever matter. In a truly representative democracy, Trump would never have happened.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoNo, that wasn't the job of the Electoral College. It was to make it so a demagogue like Trump had to win more than just the nine largest states to take power.