2 ms·
The problem with that is the rural/urban divide. If it’s just a straight majority, then rural areas despite being just under half the population will never hav
by zepto 6y ago
The problem with that is the rural/urban divide.
If it’s just a straight majority, then rural areas despite being just under half the population will never have political representation again, and indeed that disenfranchisement is part of what led to Trump’s victory in the first place.
Hunter games here we come.
- ThrowawayR2 6y agoAmen to this. If anyone is considering dismissing those areas as unimportant, rural areas are where all the food, water, natural and mineral resources, and so forth that cities depend on come from. With respect to the violence angle, rural areas also supply a huge percentage of recruits for the military, much more than major cities. Trying to disenfranchise rural areas is not going to work out well, to put it mildly. An accommodation needs to be reached between rural and urban America. I just wish we had a presidential candidate who I thought had a chance of accomplishing that.
- jfengel 6y agoPresidential candidates preferred by the rural areas have won 3 of the last 5 elections this century -- only once with a larger number of votes. There is a very good chance that they will make it 4 out of 6, again without a majority. It seems that whatever thumb they have on the scale, it overweighting them. They've also controlled at least one house of the legislature for all but two years of that time -- and for all but a few months had enough votes to veto all proposals. Changing the Electoral College wouldn't affect that. So I'd argue that "never have political representation again" is unlikely. They hardly seem disenfranchised, except in their own imagination.
- zepto 6y agoWhat you describe is a relatively balanced scenario. No serious model calls Trump’s chances ‘very good’ right now. The Economist says it’s 10%, and FiveThirtyEight says 20%. So, we’re looking at 50% of the last 6. There is no overweighting except if you imagine a Trump victory.