8 ms·
It's worth noting that this judgment does not mean Snowden's book can no longer be published; it is only a judgment against Snowden and in favor of the US gover
by pdonis 6y ago
It's worth noting that this judgment does not mean Snowden's book can no longer be published; it is only a judgment against Snowden and in favor of the US government for the money made from the book. Also, it is only the civil lawsuit, and the judgment is not connected at all with the separate criminal charges that have been filed against Snowden.
- spellczeck 6y agoAlso they misspelled judgment
- ttul 6y agoThat depends. During the 19th Century, judgement (with an 'e') became more popular in British writing and is now the common form used in British English. In legal contexts (in Britain), judgment (without an 'e') is the proper spelling. This spelling is also the dominant form in the United States. Thus, perhaps the author of the press release is British.
- spellczeck 6y agoYeah maybe it’s a fan of old English spelling, or, alternatively, the DOJ is politicized, the folks in charge are allergic to Microsoft Word, and theye donte proofreade their presse releases.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Yeah maybe it’s a fan of old English spelling The word would not have existed in old english.
- garbagetime 6y agoAre you confusing old English with Old English?
- bobbylarrybobby 6y agoIn the US, judgement can be spelled with or without that first e. Judgmental however must have only a single e.
- jchw 6y agoJudgement is actually a common and accepted spelling of judgment, either is fine. I know this because I erroneously corrected it on Wikipedia in the fairly distant past. :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- edoceo 6y agohttps://www.dictionary.com/e/judgement-vs-judgment/ https://www.dictionary.com/e/judgement-vs-judgment/ Says with the E is new, accepted and mostly British.
- schoolornot 6y agoI read the release. It seems that the judgement was awarded basically on the fact that he didn't submit it for pre-publication review. Seems unfair that punitive damages for that would be 100% of book proceeds. Especially, as I understand it, he was neither a government contractor nor releasing any new information at the time the book was published.
- nickff 6y agoI believe that the obligation to submit works for pre-publication review is the result of a contract which he signed in order to get his security clearance. My understanding is that if anyone without a security clearance had written the exact same book, there would have been no judgment.
- schoolornot 6y agoMy point is that 100% civil forfeiture for violating the agreement doesn't sit well with me considering the information was already "out there". I would have much rather preferred this action be an outcome of a criminal trial ie. Son of Sam law.
- wslack 6y agoI think this has been the policy for any/all books published without proper review.
- nickff 6y agoWell, what would you think if he'd violated a private contract, and sold a book containing the information he obtained as a result of the violation? Perhaps a lawyer doing this with respect to their relationship with a client, or maybe someone like Levandowski writing a book about what he learned at Google.
- User23 6y agoGoogle has the same deal. There is plenty of confidential information readily available on the public Internet but confirming it is still breach of contract and they will sue. I hear Apple is even more zealous about NDAs.
- molticrystal 6y agoDoes he still get proceeds for non-US sales, or does he forfeit those as well?
- jlgaddis 6y agoIt's worth noting that everything you felt worthy of noting was noted in TFA: > The United States’ lawsuit did not seek to stop or restrict the publication or distribution of Permanent Record. > On Tuesday, the court entered judgment in the government’s favor in an amount exceeding $5.2 million and imposed a constructive trust for the benefit of the United States over those sums and any further monies, royalties, or other financial advantages derived by Snowden from Permanent Record and 56 specific speeches. > This lawsuit is separate from the criminal charges brought against Snowden for his alleged disclosures of classified information. This lawsuit is a civil action, and based solely on Snowden’s failure to comply with the clear pre-publication review obligations included in his signed non-disclosure agreements. --- If no one's going to both to RTFA anymore, why do we even bother linking to them? HN could instead just be a listing of article titles and headlines.
- thaumaturgy 6y agoHere are some of the reasons I more often read comments before articles now: 1. The site doesn't render at all (I get a blank page) on my main browser because cookies are disabled on it. Reading the article requires copying the URL and switching over to another browser to load it there. 2. The site renders, but despite using uBlock, it's still laden with "Sign up for our mailing list", "accept cookies" (on my cookies-disabled browser), "Buy a subscription!", or, "you can't read any more articles from this site" popups. In the latter case, there's maybe one paragraph of content available. 3. The articles themselves are trash about half the time and on HN specifically it's not unusual to find comments that offer a little more depth on whatever the subject is. 4. Skimming the comments first is a low-effort-high-return signal for whether the article is worth clicking on anyway. 5. I don't care that much about the subject anyway, and all I really want is a two-minute update on the topic before I drag myself back to whatever I'm procrastinating on. In truth, there's been a concerted effort from a lot of different sites over the last year-plus to discourage me from reading their content directly.
- chrisweekly 6y agoMy simpler response to the same question: the signal:noise ratio of the comments is vastly superior to all but the very best and rarest articles. 95% of the value I derive from HN is from the comments.
- goldenManatee 6y agoIt’s effectively a censure. Publish and money goes to US gov, or don’t publish in States thereby limiting your target market and lose a lot of sales.