3 ms·
> Colorization and other techniques—done sincerely and as accurately as possible—are additional tools that can accomplish this in other ways. The article unfor
by jancsika 6y ago
> Colorization and other techniques—done sincerely and as accurately as possible—are additional tools that can accomplish this in other ways.
The article unfortunately doesn't point out why this is a naive take.
If you upscale an image for display on a 4k display, you can:
1. Leave an aliasing artifact intact.
2. Remove an aliasing artifact.
Now, suppose you have two clients-- one making a documentary about the moon landing, and another making a documentary about moon landing conspiracies.
Pick your favorite "sincere and accurate" ML algorithm-- it cannot generate a single image that will be suitable for use by both clients.
Perhaps "straining and toiling" is hyperbole. But I don't see an alternative to careful, deliberate study of the primary sources of history.
Also-- keep in mind that was a didactic example. When you talk about colorizing films or cartoons, things get quite muddy.