3 ms·
All right, here's a structurally similar claim: Snoring is the result of natural selection. The physical features of our throats cause snoring (we can actuall
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
All right, here's a structurally similar claim: Snoring is the result of natural selection. The physical features of our throats cause snoring (we can actually change this with surgery). And the physical features of our throats are the result of evolution. So...
So now we need to define exactly what we mean by "is the result of". Is it accidentally the result of an evolutionary process (and we are explaining it with post-hoc rationalizations)? Or is it the result of a process that evolution actually drove toward that outcome, because it was beneficial? (Or is snoring actually beneficial for the survival and reproduction of the species?)
- nendroid 6y agoAll mutations are accidental. Whether a macro feature on a biological lifeform is accidental feature or a feature driven through generations of natural selection can be judged through the complexity of the outcome. Complexity arises from random mutations being selected and building on each other. A complex module in our brain that formulates moral judgements on certain behaviors is by probability more likely to be an outcome of generations of natural selection. Such a module arising by accident is roughly equivalent to the probability of a tornado self assembling a 747 airliner from random junk by accident.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoYou're pulling out the "tornado in a junkyard" argument to advocate for evolution? There are those who think that exact same argument applies to something like morals arising as the result of a series of accidental mutations.
- nendroid 6y agoI'm not arguing against it. I'm saying morals are a macro feature arising from a series of accidental mutations as opposed to a macro feature arising as a side effect similar to your snoring example. The complexity of the moral module is too complex to be a single accidental mutation... it must be naturally selected out of a multitude of mutations building on each other to produce such a feature. This is very unlike snoring which is caused by mechanisms that are far more simplistic.