2 ms·
Think of it as translation. Should you read Dante in his original medieval Italian or in a modern English translation? Yes. But if you want to understand and ma
by mcguire 6y ago
Think of it as translation. Should you read Dante in his original medieval Italian or in a modern English translation? Yes. But if you want to understand and make strong arguments about Dante, you'll probably have to dig out the Italian.
Or, alternatively, back in the day there were these shows called "situation comedies" or sitcoms. One of them was "Three's Company." Many of the stories of the episodes of Three's Company were taken more or less directly from Shakespeare's comedies. Is it elitism to suggest that seeing a production of Shakespeare's plays is a better way of connecting with what he was trying to say than watching a '70s sitcom?
- contravariant 6y agoFair enough, but then the argument of these historians is basically equivalent to "There shouldn't be an english translation of Dante". Which I think is still a bit silly.
- 8note 6y agoI'd guess the historians would pick the sitcom. The play is pretending to be a Shakespeare production when it isn't, and will give people unrealistic views on the history, whereas the sitcom won't do that