4 ms·
I will probably get down voted about this, but I don't care. There are almost no downsides to what they're doing and the people complaining are complaining for
by oblio 6y ago
I will probably get down voted about this, but I don't care. There are almost no downsides to what they're doing and the people complaining are complaining for silly reasons.
The new term is neutral, it's shorter, the downside of renaming a branch is negligible for git.
A tempest in a teapot.
- DonaldPShimoda 6y agoPeople are making sarcastic remarks like "Oh, racism is solved now!" Obviously racism isn't solved by this, but it's a net-positive change that doesn't take much work to adapt to and is mostly unobtrusive. I don't see why that's something to get upset about, unless you endorse the maintenance of systems that can be seen as oppressive (now matter how small the oppression!). There's no good reason not to be on-board with this change.
- verroq 6y agoThe downside is that it shows the crazies in are charge and there is no one with a brain cell left to stand up to them. Just like when that lecturer was suspended for saying ne-ga. Oh a word sounds close, better punish him for racism. Oh “master”, a word that has another meaning in a totally different context, better remove it. Anyone that allows bullshit like this to happen is enabling these extremists to have their way.
- Ar-Curunir 6y agoOh no, a name changed! all our code is worthless now!
- verroq 6y agoNames have meaning. Names are important. Let’s overlook the little things so we can overlook the big things too right? Wait until they come for you when you have a minor transgression and get branded as a counter-revolutionary. This is the start of the American Cultural Revolution.
- Ar-Curunir 6y agowhat meaning does "master" have that "main" does not?
- mwambua 6y agoI think that's a reasonable argument. I just don't get the argument against using Master in the first place.
- oblio 6y agoIn summary? It offends some people. That group might be small but some other people (who some will say are overreacting and draw parallels with 1984 Newspeak) decided to not offend people for nothing. I guess the main argument is a slippery slope type of thing. What I've found, though, is that people in aggregate are reasonable. Slippery slopes almost never happen, not in the "landslide" sense. Things shift a bit, quite slowly, and at some point the shift slows down or even stops. And yes, I know about exceptions (Germany WW2, etc.). There's a reason we call them exceptions.
- type0 6y ago> In summary? It offends some people. I know, after-all there are people who are offended to anyone having a Master degree. > I know about exceptions (Germany WW2, etc.) In my case, I feel offended when anyone brings up things like that. Please stop posting this kind of comments.
- gambiting 6y agoI can't wait until we stop using the word "occupied"(as in - occupied disk space, or occupied toiled) - my own country has been occupied so hard it stopped existing for nearly 100 years, countless people have died fighting against occupation, and now just seeing the word offends me, because somehow I grew to an adult age without the ability to differentiate between intention and context. Obviously, it's nonsense. I don't have anything against github changing the names if they desire to, but I wish we called the argument behind it exactly for what it is - nonsense.
- type0 6y agoYeah right, no should ever get an occupation because of their Master's degree
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoI always thought "master" was an odd name for the primary branch anyway. Hopefully most of us can agree on that, even if we don't agree on the motivation for the change.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoIt seemed natural to me, but I came from a place where "master recording" was the reference record. But it does make zero difference what the name is, as long as it's descriptive.
- oblio 6y agoMain is pretty solid as a term, though. And the amount of people who know what a master recording is is minuscule in my experience, especially among non-native English speakers. Main is kind of obvious, even if you don't know a lot about English.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoSure. I don't really care, myself. Besides, it's just how Microsoft is deciding they want their service to work by default. It's hardly even a shift. I don't understand all the huff. The branch names were designed to be mutable in the first place.
- type0 6y agoThey should change it again and again, just for the sake of changing since developers don't deserve their sanity. That's cheap publicity. So change it to "default", afterwards change again to "trunk" after that change again to something else no-one cares anyway, it's all just great fun. Btw move to Gitlab instead!
- lioeters 6y agoI agree, we'll get used to it in a few years, and think nothing of it. I'm not totally convinced if this is an appropriate or effective response to systemic racism - compared to, say, working on company culture or donating to worthwhile causes to address the more substantial issues in society. But the fact that the new default branch name is shorter, 4 letters instead of 6, is a saving grace. I can see the value, while being skeptical of the reasoning behind it. Even those opposing the change would probably agree that it's logically a better naming.
- oblio 6y ago> I'm not totally convinced if this is an appropriate or effective response to systemic racism - compared to, say, working on company culture or donating to worthwhile causes to address the more substantial issues in society. As the meme-girl would say: "Why not both?" :-)
- Dirlewanger 6y agoIt doesn't materially solve anything aside from being an empty victory for people who can't understand the concept that words have context. It's a waste of energy and resources. All it does is cause unnecessary strife.
- arvigeus 6y agoExcept hundreds of articles / books about git using the “wrong” branch; also all the scripts that presume “master” is default. This is what every newbie programmer needs: an additional obstacle on their way learning just because some people find it cool.
- thu2111 6y agoOf course there are downsides, there are lots. The first downside is that it creates work. Yes, some tools will break, it's always going to happen when stable identifiers are renamed. No, saying "it was always theoretically possible" is not a get-out clause. Breaking software has a cost, often a large and unpredictable one. Any protocol, any API can theoretically change at any moment, which is why successful software companies often promise not to do that. Secondly and more subtly it creates work discussing it, actually doing the renames. This is time that would be spent on other useful things, but instead gets sucked up by this. Thirdly, the premise is offensive and wrong, which will anger a lot of people. The implied belief behind these changes is that the people who chose to use the word "master" before were racist. And now all this fuss has occurred, there's an even stronger implication that anyone who does not rename their branches is racist. But this isn't true and thus a deeply offensive case of false accusations on a truly epic scale. Moreover this appears to assume that language creates reality, so strongly that renaming "master" to something else will actually alter people's deeply held and embedded beliefs based on their own lifetime of experience. There's a lot of evidence this idea is completely false, in fact linguists haven't believed this for nearly 100 years. So it's anti-scientific. Fourthly, everyone knows that exactly because the premises are aggressive and irrational, it doesn't stop with this. The sort of people demanding these changes are insatiable. Once you start paying the Danegeld, you never get rid of the Dane. Next up, anywhere that uses whitelist and blacklist. You think renaming master generates an acceptable level of breakage? Wait until those two start getting renamed and a whole lot of security mechanisms stop working. What about whitespace? No, the madness (for that's what it is) will never end. The downsides to giving in to this kind of aggressive, toxic demand are limitless because there will never be a point at which the Woke Police will feel they've done enough - they will continue demanding that when they yell and get upset you dance for them, forever, until they are expelled from the communities they are attempting to take over.