3 ms·
This is a surprisingly good analysis. It ends with a comparison between Costolo’s call for violence and Trump’s. Can anyone make a case for why Costolo’s twee
by zepto 6y ago
This is a surprisingly good analysis.
It ends with a comparison between Costolo’s call for violence and Trump’s.
Can anyone make a case for why Costolo’s tweet is not a violation of twitter’s TOS’s and Trump’s is?
- uniqueid 6y agoIt's a violation of less importance than Trump's, since Costolo neither has a military nor informally controls any vigilante groups, but it's a violation, all the same. I agree the author did an excellent job of describing the situation and its pertinent angles and facets.
- zepto 6y agoI agree that there is a probabilistic argument to be made that Trump’s words are more likely to lead to violence than Costolo’s. However that seems to me to be all the distinction is. Costolo is a public figure. A multi millionaire, almost certainly richer than Trump, and there are violent activists who support his kind of rhetoric too. It seems pretty clear that Twitter not censoring his tweets the way they have with Trump is based on a political distinction. You could even see his statement as declaring Twitter itself to be an activist organization that sees revolution as inevitable and is working towards that aim. That would undermine the idea that it’s somehow at a different level of seriousness to Trump’s tweets. Costolo is talking about murdering business people whose ethics he disagrees with. He could be instead be talking about voting out Trump and reinvigorating democratic institutions, but he isn’t.
- uniqueid 6y agoI replied to a request to "make a case" that Costolo's tweet doesn't violate Twitter’s TOS. I made a case. I didn't say I subscribe to it. I don't. That's what I tried (and apparently failed) to convey by concluding "it's a violation, all the same"
- zepto 6y agoFair enough! I should have been been clear about not wanting a straw man!
- pstuart 6y agoIt's not a call for violence, not even indirectly -- he's not suggesting that they should be shot, only that they will face violence and that they had it coming.
- zepto 6y agoWhich one are you talking about?
- Jayschwa 6y ago> he's not suggesting that they should be shot Right, he's only proclaiming that he'd be happy if they were shot...
- pstuart 6y agoThe literal words: "I'll happily provide video commentary." The shooting happens when the revolution happens, which is unavoidable outcome of their behavior: "are going to be the first people lined up against the wall and shot in the revolution". Right-wing persecution complex is so funny.
- zepto 6y agoThe only people who are shot as an unavoidable consequence of their own actions are people who commit suicide or shoot themselves by accident. Anything else is consequence of someone else’s intent to kill them, or negligence.