4 ms·
Is this a purposefully-engineered flaw to reduce confidence in 3rd party chargers?
by Chris2048 6y ago
Is this a purposefully-engineered flaw to reduce confidence in 3rd party chargers?
- Tijdreiziger 6y agoIf that would've been the goal, why would they have made the device with a USB-C port in the first place (rather than a proprietary port)?
- malka 6y agoBecause Nintendo suxx as en engineering company.
- numpad0 6y agoMore like Gen 1 Switch hardware was designed too early in USB-C era. It’ll probably be fixed in future generations but Nintendo decided not to make design changes for Gen 1 and Gen 2 Switch to fully comply with USB-C PD specs.
- willis936 6y agoThe timeline here doesn’t jive. The Pixel C came out in 2015 with a USB-C port using the same SoC as the Switch (2017). Nintendo’s non-compliance is intentional.
- kalleboo 6y agoNever attribute to malice what can be attributed to incompetence. Nintendo has a long history of proprietary plugs, if they wanted to make something proprietary, they would have just done it and nobody would bat an eye, they wouldn't bother making a slightly buggy USB-C implementation. Do you also think that the Raspberry Pi 4 USB-C incompatibility is intentional? That came out waaay later
- Chris2048 6y agoOnly useful if incompetence is punished equally, otherwise every malicious actor plays dumb.
- willis936 6y agoThis is assuming Nintendo is incompetent. They have been making toys for 100 years and have been consistent pioneers in consumer electronics. They are no stranger to proprietary connectors. They opted to not develop one this time because it was seen as an unnecessary cost. Instead they took the parts of a well developed standard they liked and cut the corners they wanted to cut. They would have had a harder time finding an OTS non-compliant solution than an OTS compliant one. Playing by the standard cost too much. The only narrative here is “Nintendo sees no one is watching the cookie jar and takes from it. They prefer to be the only one with cookies anyway and don’t see the benefit of a communal jar.”, not “Nintendo don’t know what they’re doing”.