5 ms·
> "Frequent flyer" programs started as an under-the-table way to bribe corporate flyers to take one airline over another: that is, you tell your employer you wa
by arcticbull 6y ago
> "Frequent flyer" programs started as an under-the-table way to bribe corporate flyers to take one airline over another: that is, you tell your employer you want to fly Delta, your employer books you on Delta, you get a kickback.
This is a little bit more complicated.
Part of the reason that airlines used to award miles based on distance flown and not on how much you spend is that they weren't trying to incentivize business travelers.
For most business travelers, the company usually has a corporate contract requiring employees (or strongly incentivizing them) to fly on a given carrier. Otherwise, business travelers will book according to schedule (non-stop vs connecting, timing). Business travelers are also often "hub captives" -- if you're in Atlanta, you're taking Delta. As such, they often don't have discretion, so it doesn't make sense to pay incentives to a group who has no choice but to use your product.
For paid luxury travelers, they're going to be picking based on product.
The expensive fare flyers aren't going to be incentivized to the same extent as the low fares flyers by frequent flier programs. These high fare flyers pretty much pay for the flight.
So what was the deal with frequent flier programs? Once the flight is paid for, any incremental passenger you can get into the back of the bus is pure profit, and they're the most likely to engage with your ancillary products like paying to check a bag, buying food, and buying alcohol.
Historically, the idea was to convince a leisure traveler to take a 1-stop American flight instead of the non-stop on United because of the AAdvantage credit card.
Prior to the pandemic, however, load factors were so high, airlines found they didn't need to incentivize people to fly, so they decimated the value of their programs, and started awarding miles based on amount spent, and capped it per ticket. This was a large net reduction in amount of miles awarded.
- sokoloff 6y agoI'm not so sure I agree with the analysis. If you want to pack an additional leisure traveller onto your 1-stop, make it $10, maybe $20, cheaper and "mission accomplished". If you want to pull an additional business traveller onto your flight, discounting by a tiny amount doesn't help you much (if at all), but giving them something that they can personally use later does. Business travelers also have more chances per year where you can influence their decision. Getting 10 or 20 chances to land an additional short-notice and/or higher-cabin fare seems like where the money is. My company does recommend one particular carrier/group, but I have freedom to book other carriers without any fuss or extra effort on my part if the itinerary makes more sense for my trip. I do try to fly our preferred carrier, mostly because of the frequent upgrades I get and much less because of frequent flier miles. (Spouse and I use airlines once, maybe twice, per year for personal travel, so just accumulate miles which will be devalued to nearly worthless by the time we retire and travel more for leisure on airlines.)
- arcticbull 6y ago> I'm not so sure I agree with the analysis. If you want to pack an additional leisure traveller onto your 1-stop, make it $10, maybe $20, cheaper and "mission accomplished". This has to do with segmentation. Not all business travelers are allowed to fly in a premium cabin, and reducing all economy tickets to $10 wouldn't allow them to obtain maximum revenue. This is why historically airlines have priced flights cheaper earlier on (catering to leisure travelers) and raised the prices as the departure time approaches (catering to business travelers). They literally do make flights $10-20 in advance, in an attempt to snag more leisure travelers. Segmentation has gotten a lot more advanced, since, too. I agree there are some cases where companies allow free choice, although any midsize and large company I've worked at, I've been pretty strongly guided towards the companies' contracted airline -- if not mandated. For many business travelers, they're not the ones making the decision. These earning rate decisions are made for everyone, not for individuals or groups.
- sokoloff 6y agoMany business travelers are not allowed to buy a ticket for a premium cabin, but most all are allowed to fly in a premium cabin. Thus, all of the rules for upgrades in frequent flyer programs, including rules about which coded-as-main-cabin tickets are upgradeable and in what order. Even without being the very top tier of frequent flier, I am upgraded on around half of my domestic flights on our preferred carrier.
- arcticbull 6y agoYep, but that's not the part of the loyalty program I'm referring to. I'm referring to earning structure around redeemable miles. You're referring to rewarding frequent travelers, that's the status program. The status program has also been devalued tremendously as load factors go up, since there's no need to incentivize people to fly at all. > "Even without being the very top tier of frequent flier, I am upgraded on around half of my domestic flights on our preferred carrier." That depends highly on which routes, which time of day you fly, and which carrier. As a top-tier Executive Platinum on American, pre-pandemic I wouldn't ever count on getting upgraded on SFO-DFW. That's a hub-to-focus-city route with gobs of money on either side. I had like a 33% success rate. On the other hand, DFW-YUL, you can bet your life on it. An AA Silver wouldn't clear an upgrade on either, though.
- rconti 6y agoI've not worked anywhere where I was "strongly incentivized" to fly a specific airline. Also, your usage of "paid luxury travelers" is suspicious. I get that traveling on vacation is a luxury, but I feel like it implies they pay more. Businesses may get discounts for picking an airline, but what's the mix of business-class seats sold to business travelers vs personal travelers? I think it's the corporate travel that props up the whole system, even if buying at a discount.
- arcticbull 6y ago> Also, your usage of "paid luxury travelers" is suspicious. I get that traveling on vacation is a luxury, but I feel like it implies they pay more. To be clear, by "paid luxury traveler" I was referring to folks who pay for business or (proper) first-class when they travel. The well-to-do retiree or executive type. The people who pay for Lufthansa First.
- altmind 6y agoairlines award varying miles multiplier based on the seat class. its just a gimmick to call their loyalty points "miles", they can call it "tokens" with same success, as they are have no relation to miles whatsoever.
- arcticbull 6y agoBroadly speaking the term "miles" was historically due to their correlation with earning rates not redemption rates. You earned 1 base mile per mile flown (conditions apply) based on the great circle distance in statute miles from your origin to your destination (http://gcmap.com http://gcmap.com). When that correlation doesn't exist they are usually referred to as "points" instead, as in hotel programs. So airlines have miles, hotels have points.