3 ms·

I have the same Cosco car seat (use it for travel/flights). It is unusually thin because it has absolutely no side impact protection; I wouldn't recommend it fo

I have the same Cosco car seat (use it for travel/flights). It is unusually thin because it has absolutely no side impact protection; I wouldn't recommend it for anyone's daily driver: It meets the basic regulatory requirements, but absolutely nothing more. If you side by side it with a Graco or similar, there's no comparison (the build quality is just outright bad). Using one of the worst (legal) car seats on the market as a justification for why this is mistaken is misleading. If you look at any of the safer car seats they weigh more, are wider, and are wildly more popular. Parents are regularly dealing with this "three across" problem. I can easily imagine it being a consideration when looking at kid three (even with two we make different travel plans as a direct result of car seat issues). The Cosco isn't a solution, just goes to show how poorly you can get away with making a car seat.

jefftk 6y ago
There are also fancy seats that are narrow: https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B07DWB2Q3C/ https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B07DWB2Q3C/ ($200, 16") Most seats on the market are wide because they include cupholders and other extras.
- Someone1234 6y ago
  > Most seats on the market are wide because they include cupholders and other extras. Nope. They're always too wide at the head, and it is due to side impact protection/cushioning. It has nothing to do with "extras" (unless you consider safety above mandatory regulations an "extra"), since the seats are narrower at the feet. I've been in the buybuy BABY parking lot playing with store car seats, including the Radian, for up to an hour before (which is as fun as you can imagine). The Radian is specifically designed to go three across, that's essentially their niche, and they accomplish it to a certain degree. The build quality of the Radian is frankly excellent, but the kid was uncomfortable after five minutes let alone if it was a multiple hour car trip (and I can see why, very firm/minimum padding). Plus it is unpleasant to install/uninstall (particularly in rear facing). I think you've tried to prove one thing, but really proved the opposite. You've listed one car seat at the very bottom (that fits due to poor construction) and one specialty car seat that trades a lot for only 3x across. Which is essentially an admission of the reality: Most car seats don't work 3x across, it is rare, and it is problematic. Rear seats in even large SUVs have very little wall-to-wall room, you pull your average Britax or Graco car seat off the shelf, it isn't going to work 3x across. A lot of people wind up changing cars, or replacing their 1st and 2nd kid's $200 car seats to spend $600 more on three Radians (because even with one Radian and two non-Radians it doesn't work).

jefftk 6y ago

There are also fancy seats that are narrow: https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B07DWB2Q3C/ https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B07DWB2Q3C/ ($200, 16") Most seats on the market are wide because they include cupholders and other extras.

Someone1234 6y ago
> Most seats on the market are wide because they include cupholders and other extras. Nope. They're always too wide at the head, and it is due to side impact protection/cushioning. It has nothing to do with "extras" (unless you consider safety above mandatory regulations an "extra"), since the seats are narrower at the feet. I've been in the buybuy BABY parking lot playing with store car seats, including the Radian, for up to an hour before (which is as fun as you can imagine). The Radian is specifically designed to go three across, that's essentially their niche, and they accomplish it to a certain degree. The build quality of the Radian is frankly excellent, but the kid was uncomfortable after five minutes let alone if it was a multiple hour car trip (and I can see why, very firm/minimum padding). Plus it is unpleasant to install/uninstall (particularly in rear facing). I think you've tried to prove one thing, but really proved the opposite. You've listed one car seat at the very bottom (that fits due to poor construction) and one specialty car seat that trades a lot for only 3x across. Which is essentially an admission of the reality: Most car seats don't work 3x across, it is rare, and it is problematic. Rear seats in even large SUVs have very little wall-to-wall room, you pull your average Britax or Graco car seat off the shelf, it isn't going to work 3x across. A lot of people wind up changing cars, or replacing their 1st and 2nd kid's $200 car seats to spend $600 more on three Radians (because even with one Radian and two non-Radians it doesn't work).