4 ms·
> To help individuals with delusions, the current findings suggest, it may be more effective to examine their sense of control and choices than to try to convin
by vlovich123 6y ago
> To help individuals with delusions, the current findings suggest, it may be more effective to examine their sense of control and choices than to try to convince them with contradictory evidence—which, over and over, has not been shown to work.
Oh god. If that's true, you can't possibly do this at scale like you'd need for coronavirus things or global warming. I'm sure we all have delusions about something at some level. That's why trust in public institutions is critical and those institutions need to be above reproach in their conduct. That doesn't mean no bad conduct but an evidence-based belief that bad conduct is identified and punished. That could explain why American society has been crumbling. It's taken a beating on the trust aspect by abuses from those in power for a long time. More importantly there haven't really been meaningful reforms to address that abuse which has eroded the trust that was built up for so long. The "small government" movement has taken a long time but it's finally winning in America because it identified trust as the weak point & systematically kept attacking it & used media to amplify the fight. A countermovement did not form in time so here we are with so many decades of damage. I'm not sure if it's possible to rebuild that at this point.
- logicslave12 6y agoSmall government is winning because big government is filled with crooks
- vlovich123 6y agoSo now the crooks are out of government swindling you through the market in a way you don't even see? Or are you saying people's propensity for taking advantage & criminality only happens in the context of government? Or are you saying that government crooks are more efficient at swindling larger amounts than the private market offers?
- User23 6y agoTrillions are at stake over who controls the federal government, or even pieces of it. There's a reason why nobody spends $100 million a year to lobby Google but they do the government. The biggest crooks go where the biggest opportunity is, that's all.
- jrumbut 6y agoIs that true? Google is never approached by sales people? Never threatened by lawyers? Never protested by activists? Never receives petitions or gets unsolicited advice from thinktanks? I don't know about $100 million but they get their fair share of what is essentially lobbying I'm sure.
- vlovich123 6y agoIf I gave you $10 you could manage it just fine I presume by yourself. If I gave you $100 trillion, wouldn't you hire people to manage it for you & make sure it didn't get stolen from you? At a minimum, you'd pay for some physical security from anyone trying to take your riches, right?
- hnracer 6y agoSmall government and big government are both filled with crooks and self-serving bureaucrats. The main difference is that a small government can do less damage and extracts less from the economy.
- username90 6y ago> trust in public institutions is critical Distrust in public institutions is why we no longer live under despots. You need a balance.
- ardy42 6y ago> Distrust in public institutions is why we no longer live under despots. You need a balance. People don't mainly trust despots, rather they fear them. Though they may foolishly trust the "image" of the despot when they simultaneously fear the actual apparatus that he created to maintain control.
- username90 6y agoA fraction of people still blindly trust despots. The larger that fraction is the harder it is to topple the despot. If everyone was like that then the despot would never get toppled.
- 082349872349872 6y agoUnder despots, states are not public institutions, but rather private.
- username90 6y agoTo add, Democracy is more or less built around having half of all politicians actively working to reduce trust in the current government. That is intended. I think the problem in USA has more to do with how easily people are swayed by emotional arguments. It is so easy for politicians there to cause people to lose trust in a candidate just by attacking unrelated things about them.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> I think the problem in USA has more to do with how easily people are swayed by emotional arguments. It is so easy for politicians there to cause people to lose trust in a candidate just by attacking unrelated things about them. In my personal opinion as an American, I feel we've backslid a bit since ~2010. At that point, it seemed like any nearly argument could be won by invoking science (even where it wasn't applicable, such as metaphysical arguments about religion), and now science is merely one of "many Ways of Knowing" and perhaps a racist one at that. We've never had a complete trust in science, mind you, but even on the far right people wouldn't attack the very idea of science and objectivity (even if they had paranoid ideas about conspiracies in the science community and so on). I'm not sure the cause, but it concerns me deeply.
- galuggus 6y ago> To help individuals with delusions, the current findings suggest, it may be more effective to examine their sense of control and choices than to try to convince them with contradictory evidence—which, over and over, has not been shown to work. The psychiatrist Milton Ericsson, when treating a delusional patient who thought he was Jesus, said 'your a carpenter right? Could you make me some furniture?'
- etripe 6y ago> The "small government" movement has taken a long time but it's finally winning in America From the outside looking in, it's either: * the "small government" movement, which only wants to keep big government small if it's filled by the other side of the aisle and grow it otherwise, or * the "less regulation is more profits" movement Both variants are ultimately corrupt to the bone. Real small government voices don't seem to be present or growing in Washington. Then again, I don't follow your news as closely as you might.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoSmall government is nearly impossible to get from big government because the only way to change government is to get into it, and once you are in it big government is good for you. The best we can hope for is a revolution followed by a small government that grows slowly.
- vlovich123 6y agoHow are you defining "grows slowly vs grows quickly"?. What is the ideal rate of growth? The executive branch by itself has grown from 699 to 2079 since 1940 to 2014 [1]. That's a growth of just under 3x. By comparison, US population has grown from 132 million to 318 million in that time period according to Google. A growth of ~2.5x. The US GDP has grown by 14x in that time period [2]. Just to imagine that size, the US economy today is larger than the world economy in 1940 (now sure there's some inflation along with that so the numbers aren't strictly comparable. However, if you look at the total federal government size itself, it appears to haven't really changed since 1984 [3] so this growth in the executive branch is just shifting employees around. The government hasn't been growing since the 80s. So I'll reask my question. What level of growth is acceptable? Why has 0 growth in 40 years still not been enough to achieve the "ideal" "small government size"? [1] https://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/data-analysis-documentation/federal-employment-reports/historical-tables/executive-branch-civilian-employment-since-1940/ https://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/data-analysis-docu... [2] https://www.thebalance.com/us-gdp-by-year-3305543 https://www.thebalance.com/us-gdp-by-year-3305543 [3] https://www.volckeralliance.org/true-size-government https://www.volckeralliance.org/true-size-government
- dpflan 6y ago"For example, maybe voluntary mask-wearing should be encouraged and coupled with rewards for choosing to put on a face covering and occasional punishments for not doing so." We have seen mask non-compliance fines go into effect, but perhaps there needs to be mask compliance rewards. I frequent a coffee shop that has been providing a mask-discount since March.
- vmception 6y agoThese days I tell confrontational anti-mask people, in this order "My mask is for just in case I need to go into a shop" "I like the fashion accessory, this mask was personalized" "yeah you got me, I don't actually care about these rights being curbed, go away"
- Viliam1234 6y agoMaybe we just need more masks that stop viruses but let the coffee get through.
- hnracer 6y agoI think Trump and the divisions in the US are a symptom of the wokeness that sprung up in the mid 2010s, and that wokeness came from the humanities departments in US colleges who proselytized to and converted a large swathe of millennial graduates. Now a large proportion of the population doesn't care who they elect as long as they aren't towing the politically correct line which is being forced upon them by US cultural institutions (primarily media and entertainment, who were capture by recent woke graduates) Source: (1) people I know who are Republicans, (2) check out any right media outlet and the primary outrage is wokeness.