3 ms·
And just like programming, there are versions of those with easier notation to ease entry. Anyone remember all the different ways music was represented as they
by Waterluvian 6y ago
And just like programming, there are versions of those with easier notation to ease entry.
Anyone remember all the different ways music was represented as they grew up? What about guitar tabs? I remember simplified math as a kid.
I think this hits on the right approach, which already exists: different languages with different complexity levels for notation.
- FartyMcFarter 6y agoIt's interesting that guitar tabs are quite close to old tablature notation, which was used for lots of string instruments such as the lute. Renaissance lute music is usually tabbed.
- Waterluvian 6y agoThanks for sharing. I had no idea. I think it’s a really interesting approach of stripping away a ton of information and relying on the musician having heard the music before.
- beagle3 6y ago> Anyone remember all the different ways music was represented as they grew up? What about guitar tabs? I remember simplified math as a kid. I don't remember different notations for math and music as a kid... Music was always sheet music, even when I learned classical guiter; Chord names were "procedures", at times spelled out, and sometimes only referenced. Guitar tabs exist, but were only for people who wanted to play without taking the time to actually learn the craft (at least when I was growing up) EDIT: This was the attitude of every teacher around me growing up, not mine. As for math - other than having variables written down as empty squares, circles, triangles and stars which were later replaced by letters, I think the first real simplification of math notation that I met was Einstein summation; Everything else was just building on previous things, sometimes with new concepts (like complex numbers) and sometimes as shortcuts (limits and infinites). But they were all shorter than what they replaced, and compatible. > I think this hits on the right approach, which already exists: different languages with different complexity levels for notation. There was a guy who proposed something along the article's lines in 1958, which went even farther - instead of "single word descriptions", he chose a single symbol graphical description, because -- though ignored by the author of this article -- most of the world does not have English as their first language. I like the result of that 1958 suggestion a lot; most people place a SEP field over it. The guy is called Kenneth Iverson and the language is called APL with modern descendants J and K.
- matthewmacleod 6y agoGuitar tabs exist, but were only for people who wanted to play without taking the time to actually learn the craft This attitude really rubs me the wrong way. Tablature is absolutely ancient. It's been around for hundreds of years, and this glib dismissal is just the absolutely epitome of an elitist mindset.
- beagle3 6y agoI just added an edit: I wrote this, but this wasn't my mindset -- that was the mindset of every teacher and adult around me growing up, including those who couldn't read sheet music and used tablature to play. (Yes, I did grow up in a culture highly inspired by older/east european ideals, where kids were welcome to do whatever they want such as learn the guitar, after they've finished their homework, practiced their piano lessons. And as long they're on a path that -- if kept -- would lead them to be on a professional level) I played classical guitar for a few years, but stopped because I just wanted to play popular music, and there were no teachers around who actually taught that who were accomplished enough to be considered worth the money by my parents (who had a very limited budget).
- andrewzah 6y agoThe fact that tablature is ancient doesn't mean it's great for "learning the craft" (in other words, understanding music theory). The age of a notation system is completely irrelevant when deciding what notation system to use, really. Tablature (for guitar/bass guitar, anyway) reduces note and rhythm information to merely a fret# on a string. This is perfectly fine for people who just want to play a song. I look at tabs sometimes for a quick reference since it's just mentally easier than sheet music. But if you want to start understanding the theory and relationships between those notes and chords to any meaningful degree, you really do need to start using sheet music. "Fret #3 on the E string to Fret #3 on the A string" doesn't communicate information like "G -> C" does (like the key center, the tonic, etc). It also doesn't limit you to any specific section of the fretboard. Sheet music is really not that hard to learn. If you want to just use tabs, go ahead, but it's not elitist to point out that sheet music is basically essential for progression as a musician. Music theory is a fundamental part of that progression, unless you just want to play tablature (or sheet music) robotically.