3 ms·
> But take the idea of having to use synthetic fertilizers and pest control. There are better ways, but they eat at the profit margin if you were only to maximi
by roenxi 6y ago
> But take the idea of having to use synthetic fertilizers and pest control. There are better ways, but they eat at the profit margin if you were only to maximize on profit, yield, and market value.
Society relies on their being massive agricultural surplus so that only a few people need to be farmers and the rest of us can go and do other things.
If farm yields drop, more land (and people) need to be farmers. If profit margins shrink from changes in farming technique, then either either less is being produced (again, requiring more land & farmers) or more resources being consumed (requiring more raw materials being diverted away from producing comfort and towards producing food).
Profits and yields are not small matters, they are ratios in the equation of how many people we free up from being farmers. We have made enormous strides by freeing up people from toiling away as farmers. There is a long debate to be had about whether taking steps to wind that back is a good idea.
- crispyambulance 6y ago> There is a long debate to be had about whether taking steps to wind that back is a good idea. It depends on what you exactly mean by "winding that back". Putting ecological and global warming concerns on the table-of-consideration along with market imperatives is not only reasonable but responsible. Ironically, the best example of profit/yield imperatives above all else is the corn/fructose industry. This industry is heavily subsidized because of decades of political finagling. They're bad for the environment and not really profitable without subsidies. The corn industry has "won" the race to the bottom and maximized yield at the expense of everything else. Supply chain technologies are now starting to enable small farmers to provide sustainable goods and still make a living without being a cog in a huge corporation. Suppliers are increasingly doing that. Is it going to completely replace the corn/fructose industry? no, but it can move us in the right direction over time.
- catawbasam 6y agoYou seem to believe fewer farmers is better. There are people out who would like to be farmers but can't pull it off because the current system makes it hard to start small and build up.
- andrey_utkin 6y agoDo you realize that if the price of food rises, some people on the low side of the income distribution will starve immediately? Some of them will happen to be the ones dreaming of becoming independent farmers.
- jjk166 6y agoAnd if existing farms become less productive, you need more land and more capital investment to start a farm. When GP talks about more labor being needed for food production, these are not more farmers, these are more field hands and laborers.