4 ms·
Pretty much every serious problem facing humanity in 2020 is the consequence of over-industrialization, but more specifically, over-consumerization. To conflate
by keiferski 6y ago
Pretty much every serious problem facing humanity in 2020 is the consequence of over-industrialization, but more specifically, over-consumerization. To conflate the two is to miss a fundamental point about modern consumer capitalism.
Virtually all of the "basic accomplishments" listed in the article add up to about 1% (a rough estimate) of the actual industrial output today. It's unclear to me how say, the mass apparel industry (clothes, shoes, etc.), which is about 10% of Co2 emissions, [1] could be considered "progress" or anything other than a massive consumerism disaster...and I say that as someone with a deep respect for the art and craft of fashion designers.
Now, you might say "we would never have these developments without mass industrialization and consumerism." Maybe, but I'm of the opinion that a pretty significant part of the modern economy is both frivolous and ecologically disastrous. Is it really "progress" to have IKEA disposable furniture at the cost of cutting down forests? Etc.
1. https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2019/09/23/costo-moda-medio-ambiente https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2019/09/23/costo-m...
> The fashion industry is responsible for 10 % of annual global carbon emissions, more than all international flights and maritime shipping.
- NalNezumi 6y agoBut the authors point does neither miss the fundamental point about modern consumer capitalism, or refute it, in my option. Being Industrially literate as the author claim one should be seems to be about acknowledging the good part of industrialization, hence he focuses on the achievements we have gained through industrialization that we hold very dear (health, safety, etc). This is not the same as justifying the fashion industry practices you point out. On contrary, with the knowledge of good industrial effect (and it's side effects) maybe we can make a better judgement on the solution to it. We can see that certain industrial practice(such as fashion) should not be seen with the same respect as the one mentioned, instead of just black & white paint all of industrialization. Hence the mention of Chesterton's Fence at the end.
- keiferski 6y agoThe article is written from a very Whig-oriented, "Progress" point of view. The facts listed are all presented as unquestionably good. > When you know these facts of history—which many schools do not teach—you understand what “industrial civilization” is and why it is the benefactor of everyone who is lucky enough to live in it. It's basically an over-simplified account of history, in which scientific progress and consumer capitalism are inextricable. That is the point I'm making.
- NalNezumi 6y agoNot American, so had to look up what Whig-oriented was, but fair point! I saw the scientific progress between the lines(fertilizer, pesticide, all the technological advancement the bullet-point example describes) but you have a very valid point that it should have been mentioned. (I can't comment too much on consumer capitalism though, as I don't know much there)
- username90 6y ago> industrialization and consumerism Why did you link the two? The article doesn't mention consumerism. There was no point like "without industrialization people couldn't buy a new expensive smartphone every couple of years" or "without industrialization women wouldn't be able to have 50 bags each".
- keiferski 6y agoThe fact that it doesn't mention consumerism is precisely my point. The article argues for a number of things which supposedly are necessary for basic modern "quality of life", but are actually just necessary for consumerism. Plastic is a great example. Absolutely necessary in some medical or high-tech contexts, but absolutely unnecessary for most packaging and consumer goods.