4 ms·
> We estimate that these laws prevented only 57 car crash fatalities of children nationwide in 2017 That cannot be properly evaluated without considering secon
by kazinator 6y ago
> We estimate that these laws prevented only 57 car crash fatalities of children nationwide in 2017
That cannot be properly evaluated without considering second and additional order effects, like everyone driving huge SUVs to fit these child seats. All else is never equal.
> western society has a problem of "safety at any cost"
No, I think just America. Europe isn't so safety crazed.
For instance, it's common for Europeans not to wear bicycle helmets.
- tshaddox 6y agoIt’s extremely common for Americans to not wear bicycle helmets.
- pletnes 6y agoSince they don’t bicycle, you mean?
- kortilla 6y agoNo, the ones that do bicycle frequently don’t wear helmets. The percentage varies widely based on city.
- deathgrips 6y agoYes, they just need to magically shrink the distances between cities
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hobofan 6y agoI'm not sure if there is a big cultural divided regarding wearing helmets for safety reasons. Anecdotally it's most strongly driven by "competition" with cars: - Small city -> Not that much traffic -> No helments - Big city with lacking bike infrastructure/no strong biking culture -> A lot of close encounters with cars -> Helmets - Big city with established biking culture -> No helmets
- IncRnd 6y agoI think you have an inherent bias in your examples. There are bike riders outside of cities.
- hobofan 6y agoIf you mean rural travel between small cities/towns, that's what I head in mind too with the first example (as that's the setting I grew up in). If you mean sport biking (race, mountainbike, long distance), then you are right that I didn't consider those.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Oricle 6y agoSo what! Fucking good goyhim you idiots are
- cs02rm0 6y agoNo, I think just America. Europe isn't so safety crazed. For instance, it's common for Europeans not to wear bicycle helmets. That doesn't hold for the UK. Maybe it's spreading.
- Thlom 6y agoIt's common to ride without a helmet in countries where cycling is a normal activity. Basically Netherlands, Denmark, parts of Belgium, Germany and France. Where cycling is mostly a leisure activity on the weekends and for enthusiasts, helmet usage is much higher.
- toyg 6y agoI never considered the possibility of wearing a helmet on a bike in non-competitive settings in Italy. Only after I moved to the UK (and had children), did I start using it regularly. To this day I’m not sure whether it’s compulsory or not, but most people have it, so...
- pja 6y agoIt's not compulsory in the UK to wear cycle helmets. There has been the occasional attempt to pass such a law in the past, but none were successful. Cyclist organisations are very averse to helmet laws, seeing them as marking cycling out as some unusually dangerous activity, which in turn has an inevitable negative effect on cyclist numbers.
- cycomanic 6y ago> > We estimate that these laws prevented only 57 car crash fatalities of children nationwide in 2017 > That cannot be properly evaluated without considering second and additional order effects, like everyone driving huge SUVs to fit these child seats. All else is never equal. > > western society has a problem of "safety at any cost" > No, I think just America. Europe isn't so safety crazed. I would say that is a gross oversimplification. It depends a lot on country, on safety "area" etc.. For instance most European countries have much stricter laws around car safety (e.g. in Germany you have to get an extensive safety check every couple of years) and driver licences. Regarding bicycle helmets I think this is much more a function of when the cycling culture developed in the country, e.g. in the Netherlands, Germany, Denmark biking has been a common way of commuting for a long time (way before helmets came about) and helmets are not that common, while in Sweden for instance most cyclists were helmets.
- PaulAJ 6y agoActually we just focus our efforts on making sure everyone has potable water.
- jaclaz 6y ago>No, I think just America. Europe isn't so safety crazed. Well, US are crazy about reponsabilities (the "objects seen in this mirror ...") more than safety. The EU (generally speaking) tends to be more attentive to some more practical aspects of safety, as an other commenter noted periodical revisions/check of cars, or fire regulations tend to be much stricter than the US. But - cannot say in other EU countries - here (Italy) we have our own forms of craziness. Back to the children seats, we have now a new norm mandating an alarm (also via Bluetooth and/or SMS) on seats to prevent parents forgetting toddlers strapped to the seat and walking away after having parked the car. Italian, not too bad on Google translate: https://www.automobile.it/magazine/burocrazia/seggiolino-anti-abbandono-6905 https://www.automobile.it/magazine/burocrazia/seggiolino-ant... There were countrywide a very small number of child deaths for this reason (8 or 9 documented cases in the last 20 year or so), and while this is extremely sad it doesn't seem to me like it jutifies the provision.