4 ms·
One comment buried in this thread manages to note what I think is the key error here. The article claims that the parts for building are not sufficently standa
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
One comment buried in this thread manages to note what I think is the key error here.
The article claims that the parts for building are not sufficently standardized. That's certainly a claim to make, but you can't just accept that as-is.
The parts for building almost housing stock in a given country are almost completely standardized (they may vary from country to country, of course). What the authors mean, but do not say, is really "the standardization has occured only at the smallest scales".
Studs, joists, shingles, plumbing, electrical, block work, window and door sizes, plumbing connectivity, and so much more are all more or less completely standardized. There are options to break with the standards and get (for example) a one-off doorway sizing.
What the authors want, but do not say, are modular components of larger scale: entire walls, or entire rooms, or entire buildings that one can put together.
They might be right to want this, or they might be wrong. If software was any useful evidence, they're probably wrong. But this is not at the same thing as saying "things are not standardized and should be". The small scale components of buildings are extremely standardized in most industrial nations of the world.
- Accujack 6y agoYep, probably wrong. There's a truism in architecture: "Buildings are built for people." Not to be works of art or cultural enhancements, but to serve a need. I think it applies here, too. A home is one of the most personal possessions anyone can own. Although you can make arguments all day long about efficiencies in design and mass production, I think just about everyone in the world who owns a home would much rather have one designed to fit them and their purpose, not one made from large scale standard parts. I say this as someone who has a number of unusual things desired in a home, and who has had a lot of difficulty deviating from "standards" for home use. The efficiency benefit of standardization is also a standardized jail for people who want to do something different. There's a place in the market for cookie cutter homes if costs must be reduced to minimum or construction time must be minimized, but in pretty much every other instance, people want the opposite of what this company is selling.