3 ms·
What we have right now is partially privatized schooling with a public back-up. The private schools don't have to deal with the problem of capacity in general,
by analog31 6y ago
What we have right now is partially privatized schooling with a public back-up. The private schools don't have to deal with the problem of capacity in general, and in the geographic distribution of capacity in particular. They don't have to provide capacity for special needs kids.
You can choose a prime location to build a private school for 100 kids, and be reasonably assured that it will be filled with 100 kids. If not, it shuts down and the kids go elsewhere or back to the public schools. This happens sometimes.
And while the training of teachers is certainly a worthy matter of debate, the hiring of teachers by public schools is coupled with a standardization of teacher training and a guarantee of reasonable wages thanks to the union.
I predict where it ends is a small number of companies form an oligopoly of private school operators that are perpetually bailed out by the government. I also predict the emergence of local or even regional "school deserts" where families have no school options.
- primrose 6y agoMarket forces fix all of this. Give vouchers and let the parent's decide.
- analog31 6y agoAvailability will dictate choice to a large extent unless there is a fair amount of overcapacity. What if there are no schools with available capacity within, say, 40 miles? What if a large region has exactly one company operating schools? What if that company goes out of business during the school year? Why aren't other countries lining up to try voucher schools? Let's see some success stories. What are the choice criteria that parents are supposed to sort out when trying to get their kid into an available seat?
- primrose 6y agoWhat if there's not a(n) _______ with in 40 miles? Yet loads of people live 40 miles away from a lot of things. Somehow the market provides for them. "What if a large region has exactly one company operating schools?" Like today with government run schools? "What if that company goes out of business during the school year?" Fair point. Are you assuming there won't be competition? Stager voucher payments through out the school year. "Why aren't other countries lining up to try voucher schools?" Indoctrination. Very effective way of controlling thought. I would recommend reading the origins of US schooling, from Prussia. https://www.forcedschool.com/post/69947261758/the-prussian-model https://www.forcedschool.com/post/69947261758/the-prussian-m... "Let's see some success stories." Denmark. Education dollars are tied to the student not the school district. Their kids are pretty smart. "What are the choice criteria that parents are supposed to sort out when trying to get their kid into an available seat?" More choice then what they currently have. Markets, devoid of gov incentives (unlike health care and education), do a good job with oversupply.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- analog31 6y agoDon't worry, _______ will provide. Of course the Prussian cabal has been secretly controlling our schools for as long as Prussia has been a country, but effectively? And I don't see voucher schools in my state offering radically different education, but rather, just doing the same thing with better discipline and fewer special needs kids. Most children in Denmark attend public schools. They have a limited number of private schools, backed up by the public school system, just like I described above.
- primrose 6y ago"Don't worry, _______ will provide." I know. Capitalism is great! "Of course the Prussian cabal has been secretly controlling our schools for as long as Prussia has been a country, but effectively?" Prussia set the model. Our country uses it for our country's indoctrination. Not a hard concept. "And I don't see voucher schools in my state offering radically different education, but rather, just doing the same thing with better discipline and fewer special needs kids." Why? "Most children in Denmark attend public schools." But the funds are tied to the children, not the school district. Doing so would create more competition in existing public schools.
- analog31 6y ago>>>> I know. Capitalism is great! I was thinking "God will provide," equally hypothetical. >>>> Prussia set the model. Our country uses it for our country's indoctrination. Not a hard concept. But effectively? Prove that our schools are actually carrying out indoctrination. It's not even measured. How would we know? The origins and even structural similarities don't prove the intention or outcome of contemporary education. You have to show that what you're claiming is actually happening. >>>> Why? Ask them. Probably because of parental demand, and it's an easy formula. If charter schools are loosely modeled on the public school formula, it's easier to move kids in and out, and to hire teachers. >>>> But the funds are tied to the children, not the school district. Doing so would create more competition in existing public schools. You have to prove an actual effect on competition. Without overcapacity, slotting kids into schools is a zero sum game. The system may be quite stable over time, which might suggest that something other than competition is driving quality.