2 ms·
I think your implementation is really, really cool. Similarly I spent a good half hour bumbling through Cosmopolitan. Love what you've built. IMO, the fact tha
by arcticbull 6y ago
I think your implementation is really, really cool. Similarly I spent a good half hour bumbling through Cosmopolitan. Love what you've built.
IMO, the fact that asm() is used for a bunch of things unrelated to inline assembly -- but to your point, instead for changing compiler behaviors is more of an argument for exposing additional __attributes__, annotations and so on, rather than adding explicit support for asm() to the standard. This violates the principal of least surprise, and IMO, serves to further confuse rather than bring some predictability to C.
I'd suggest also that C should embrace some movement in the standard rather than agreeing to leave things as is forever and stapling legs onto the octopus that is C++. There was a good writeup here a while ago from someone involved with the committee, that they've gotten to the point where introducing new warnings for obviously broken behavior is off the table because they want to be warnings-compatible from release to release.
What I'm saying is I would rather see exposed intrinsics, primitives and other meaningful source annotations than codifying the spooky action at a distance of an empty string asm() call in the C standard. And if we're going to modify the standard there's a lot of low-hanging fruit I'd love to see cleaned up first.
[edit] I'd also like to add that I agree with your thesis that if this can be built with the tools provided instead of modifying the standard, that the onus is on the proposer. Based on some of the other analyses here it seems like it can't really be done in a universal way, but I'm open minded.