3 ms·
Why is someone being downvoted for saying factual information? Vietnam has also done so.
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Why is someone being downvoted for saying factual information? Vietnam has also done so.
- mrguyorama 6y agoI'm guessing some people are skeptical about China's claims about having no more cases. It's hard to trust anything they say. That or they are so hardcore crazy "My freedoms above all else" that they would rather 250k die than they be asked to stay in for a few weeks
- sudosysgen 6y agoSure, but this isn't evidence based skepticism, it's just unfounded skepticism. In any case, Vietnam used the same tactics and arrived to the same result, so I don't understand why anything else would be expect for the same tactics being implemented in China.
- hurrdurr2 6y agoTurns out HN is just another ideological bubble where wrong-think is actively discouraged via the voting system. Edit: Pretty "unfortunate".
- pessimizer 6y ago"Ironic" isn't a synonym for "unfortunate," "unusual," "ineffective," or "sarcastic."
- hurrdurr2 6y agoTypical HN comment. Being pedantic versus arguing the point.
- mellosouls 6y agoIt's evidence-based in the sense that China has long established itself as a society with a poor human rights and censorship record. Clearly any announcements that suggest an outlier positive performance in this situation will be taken with a pinch of salt, regardless of whether they are true or not.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe issue is that hiding the millions of cases there would be if the virus was not eradicated given the end of all containment measures would be completely impossible. Also, this isn't outlier-positive performance, it is the expectation given the measures that were taken. I don't see how the virus could spread with the strict measures that were imposed.
- throwmeaway_pls 6y agoBoth Vietnam and China have a track record of covering up disease outbreaks. They also both use homegrown tests for COVID-19. It is not unreasonable to discount their figures without independent verification.
- vkou 6y agoI understand why you would think this might be the case - but please consider the logistical difficulties of such a vast conspiracy. There's over a billion people in China, with an extensive diaspora that keeps in touch with family back home. The world is connected, and we aren't living in 1929 anymore (Where your entire extended family could have starved to death, and you wouldn't hear about it for a decade.) What exactly do you think is happening there? They've lifted the lockdowns - and if the virus were still circulating through the community, it should have infected tens of millions of people by now. Do you think that millions of people are getting sick and dying, and their overseas relatives, who are frequently in touch with them, don't know about it? They've tried to suppress COVID information, when only thousands of people were infected in January, and... Everybody still knew about it. Do you think they are somehow orders of magnitude more successful at doing so in September, while secretly having millions and tens of millions of cases? Or is the more plausible explanation that they probably don't have millions and tens of millions of cases? Or, alternatively, do you think that they only have tens and hundreds of thousands of cases (Few enough to suppress information on), and somehow, despite the lockdowns being lifted, they aren't ballooning into millions?
- hurrdurr2 6y agoMy Chinese friends who live in multiple different cities are all telling me the pandemic is pretty much over where they are located. Businesses are basically back to normal. Even mask wearing is not as widespread as it used to be out in the open (still required in most indoor spaces). I guess they must all be CCP stooges and are lying to me. People thinks the CCP is some omnipotent organization and can suppress any and all information. If that's the case, then how do we even know about the Uyghur detention camps?
- sudosysgen 6y ago
- chrisco255 6y agoIt's been over 6 months. And being asked to is quite different than being bolted into your apartment complex: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ald2FIAGRvs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ald2FIAGRvs
- pessimizer 6y ago> It's been over 6 months. For us. It's been over for them for a while.
- chrisco255 6y agoFor China? How long exactly, mate? You got CCP sanctioned stats on this? How reliable are they, by the way?
- hurrdurr2 6y agoBecause HN, in general, hates China with a passion. Please self-censor and refrain from saying anything positive about China in the future or you will be down-voted to oblivion.