5 ms·
What a terrible article. Really damaging. Yes, economic inequality is a major issue and ‘intersects’ with everything. But the dynamics of social networks are
by zepto 6y ago
What a terrible article. Really damaging.
Yes, economic inequality is a major issue and ‘intersects’ with everything.
But the dynamics of social networks are absolutely a problem independent of that, and it’s important for people to be able to reason about that without collapsing it into ‘capitalism bad’.
- grawprog 6y agoI guess that depends on which side of the economic equality fence you're on.
- zepto 6y agoI’m not sure I follow you? Are you saying that poorer people can’t or maybe shouldn’t think about complex issues?
- grawprog 6y agoNo i'm saying economic equality becomes more important than those issues. When money isn't a problem, you have the time and resources to care about those things, when money is a problem, money becomes more important because Money == food,water and shelter https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow's_hierarchy_of_needs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow's_hierarchy_of_needs
- lazypenguin 6y agoI wouldn't ignore the case where those higher level issues start to cause you to have less money, food and water because you are being manipulated to act against your own interests.
- zepto 6y agoYou say ‘no’ but then you present an argument which seems to evaluate to ‘yes’. If you are saying that a person who actually doesn’t have access to food, water, and shelter don’t have time to think about the problems of social media, I’d say there is merit to that. But then that seems like a clear ‘yes’ to my question. It also supports my original comment about how terrible the piece is. By your logic, someone in such a position can’t or shouldn’t be reading a Slate article discussing the relative importance of these issues.
- lefrenchy 6y agoAre social networks inherently bad on their own as you seem to imply though? Don’t you think maximizing profit is one of the root problems. Don’t you think the platforms aren’t built to have the most social good, but instead to maximize shareholder value?
- kordlessagain 6y agoMaximizing profit is only a problem if the user model in the code isn't tied directly to the customer payment model. In the case of a social network like Twitter or Facebook, the payment models are embodied in advertiser customer classes, not user classes. If you sign up for Twitter, for example, you don't get a payment model assigned to you that is then optimized to encourage you to continue to pay for the service. Yes, Twitter has user payment models, but those are payment models for self-promotion, which ends up making your interests (as a customer model) more important than mine (as a user model), which just ends up being the same problem all over again. Code that unifies the user and customer models are likely to be more "user friendly" given they don't put a priority on growth of a model that lies outside the user model. Those types of models can focus on what the users want, collectively, and may even profit from making the user's lives better from the use of the product. If anyone here has built or maintained an app and that app has separate user and customer models, then you are part of this problem!
- lefrenchy 6y agoI agree that free products like Twitter or Facebook create this problem since advertisers, politicians, and media become the customers, and user attention and engagement becomes the product. I still think the underlying problem is profit though, since these companies offer free product in order to get the largest user base (since social networks benefit from this scale). Maximizing user base size leads to more profit since they have more and larger media, politician, and advertising customers. Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram would not be anywhere near as successful if all the users were required to pay a subscription fee. It's an inherent contradiction between social networks and profit that cannot, in my view at least, be resolved.
- canb3 6y agoWhy? You’re able to box this out in a customized context (and it is since social political intuition is subjective to one’s experience). It’s important to be able to think critically and with nuance, of course, why must avoiding “harming capitalism” when capitalism causes tons of harm across contexts of science and culture, be avoided? It’s not a person it’s ideological guidelines. Surely jabbing at any ideology as frequently as the public wishes must be tolerated in a free society. So why the boxing in and protectionism of capitalism at all? Whatever this reality is it’s obviously only moving towards it’s destruction. Why should clinging to historical emotional objects be a priority of our critical thinking education in a universe smashing itself apart? Why capitalism? Or Catholicism? Certainly other frameworks would achieve a similar statistical balance of haves versus have nots, since real logistical distribution mirrors monarchism, and other historical hierarchies. If that’s what we’re going for, why the pretense? Just legislate gamed logistical distribution as a goal. No need for syntactic jargon unless the real goal is obscurantism. Numbers don’t lie: capitalism is just another generational emotional game, obligation to defer to hierarchy, like the others humanity binned. What’s so important about it?
- zepto 6y agoIs this meant to be a response to me? Why are you talking about ‘not harming capitalism’? What has that got to do with anything?
- deeperthinker 6y agoI do not think you understand capitalism, which can only be done in historical context, and is a misnomer. The actual term is private property rights. Do you believe that if I build a house, the mob either directly or through a central authority should be empowered to take it from me and give it to someone else ? The counterparts to capitalism are feudalism where a small set of people - the aristocrats are empowered to take resources from everyone else, or communism where the state is empowered to do the same, or some version of socialism where the general public is. The important thing about capitalism is you have rights to your own resources and no one , absolutely no one should be able to take it from one without assent. Assent to taxes is a different beast because there is a social contract between government and people to provide common goods which either are too expensive for individuals to provide themselves or the returns from investments are public like basic education is a requirement for a cohesive society and understanding of basic democratic concepts through the spread of education, so this is a public good that taxation should be used for, others include national defense, impartial judiciary, policing, transportation networks, public regulation.