4 ms·
If you're referring to my comments, I'm probably the only person in this thread who works professionally in two-way satellite. My day to day work encompasses th
by walrus01 6y ago
If you're referring to my comments, I'm probably the only person in this thread who works professionally in two-way satellite. My day to day work encompasses the venn diagram overlap between terrestrial ISP backbone network engineering, point-to-point high capacity microwave and millimeter wave band transport links, and various two-way satellite access technologies when a link via geostationary is the only viable option.
And I don't dislike Starlink. I actually think it's amazing tech. I'm criticizing the specific PR stunt of putting a starlink CPE at an exising ILEC CO, not what Starlink is.
Starlink, when ready for ordinary end user production use, will be an amazing improvement over cheap ($110-200/mo) consumer grade VSAT terminals. The physics and economics of launching 4000-6200 kg geostationary telecom satellites and their extremely limited aggregate capacity means that a consumer grade VSAT must be oversubscribed at a 32:1 ratio or worse. Resulting in terrible things like 60GB/month data quotas for end users. It's overall a miserable experience. Starlink has the potential to entirely disrupt and kill what I call the 'shitty VSAT' market.
Above the 'shitty VSAT' market there's a whole category of serious two way satellite technology that the ordinary consumer will never see. And things like o3b and starlink also have the potential to improve that. You would visibly cringe if you saw the monthly $ per MHz transponder costs for Ku spot beam capacity over eastern Africa. The dollars per Mbps ratio is ridiculously bad. In order to achieve any reasonable bps/Hz modulation density you can easily spend $100k to erect a pair of 4.5m size earth stations for a dedicated 1:1, SCPC link. And that's before you're looking at anywhere from $5000 to $30,000/month paid for transponder capacity, depending on how much data you're trying to move, and how asymmetric it is.
There's a reason why every telecom/ISP in every developing nation is trying their hardest to connect to the nearest submarine cable landing station and not remain reliant upon monthly C or Ku band transponder leases.
- InvaderFizz 6y ago> There's a reason why every telecom/ISP in every developing nation is trying their hardest to connect to the nearest submarine cable landing station and not remain reliant upon monthly C or Ku band transponder leases. It's not just cost, it's also the latency. While it's apparent you know this, most commenters might not realize the game changing difference with Starlink. Starlink latency can be as low as 15ms to the nearest POP. The minimum latency for any geostationary satellite to the nearest pop is 528ms RTT. That's speed of light, going 28k miles 4x, assuming you and the POP are on the equator directly below the satellite.
- walrus01 6y agoyes, that as well. FYI minimum latency for a round trip ICMP ping on geostationary is more like 492-495ms. 520-525ms is also typical. Will vary somewhat with modem FEC complexity, FEC code rate, and exactly what modems are in use on a 1:1 dedicated link.
- InvaderFizz 6y agoAmazing how just a nugget of bad info can change things. Back in Satellite Controller school in 2003 we were taught geostationary is 28,500 miles. So even since then I've been using that as my reference point. In reality, it's about 35,786km, or 22,236 miles[0]. That means the minimum RTT time is 479ms, given the perfect scenario I previously laid out and zero equipment delay. Which isn't a thing. Then again, the mythical perfectly spherical radiation pattern dipole antenna that we base all dBi off of isn't a thing either. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geostationary_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geostationary_orbit
- walrus01 6y agoOne of the tradeoffs in modern state of the art VSAT modems is that you can intentionally choose more computationally 'expensive' FEC, to slightly improve your bps/Hz in a given fixed kHz/MHz amount of FDD transponder capacity, at the expense of higher latency. With the Comtech CDM-760 for instance. This is getting better as the years go on and modem manufacturers are able to throw additional CPU and FPGA resources at FEC processing, without increasing their cost to build a modem a great deal.
- iso1210 6y ago35,786km above the equator. Equator is 6,378km from the centre of the earth, so GEO is 42,164km, or 26,200 miles, so not sure where 28,500 came from. > Then again, the mythical perfectly spherical radiation pattern dipole antenna that we base all dBi off of isn't a thing either. It got knocked over by a spherical cow. (I did have a colleague lose a satellite connection in Libya once which he blamed on a herd of cows. I think he aiming fairly low on the horizon to the east, with the disk near ground level, so I give him the benefit of the doubt)
- matmatmatmat 6y ago"Starlink, when ready for ordinary end user production use, will be an amazing improvement over cheap ($110-200/mo) consumer grade VSAT terminals. The physics and economics of launching 4000-6200 kg geostationary telecom satellites and their extremely limited aggregate capacity means that a consumer grade VSAT must be oversubscribed at a 32:1 ratio or worse. Resulting in terrible things like 60GB/month data quotas for end users. It's overall a miserable experience. Starlink has the potential to entirely disrupt and kill what I call the 'shitty VSAT' market." Actually, GEO satellites have quite a bit of aggregate capacity (1 Tbps and going up) and more capacity where it matters (over land, and specifically, population centers) than LEO constellations, and therefore have better bandwidth economics. They also last ~3x as long, which brings the $/Mbps down more. 60 GB/month caps are not really a thing anymore, unless you're still using HughesNet. Latency will be dealt with using hybrid modems that can use LEO/DSL/4G for latency-sensitive applications and GEO for large amounts of cheap bits. Hughes, to their credit, has had such a solution available since 2007, last I checked.
- walrus01 6y ago> Actually, GEO satellites have quite a bit of aggregate capacity (1 Tbps and going up) and more capacity where it matters (over land, and specifically, population centers) than LEO constellations, and therefore have better bandwidth economics. They also last ~3x as long, which brings the $/Mbps down more. the aggregate capacity of a 180 million dollar (construction plus launch cost) 6000 kg geostationary telecom satellite is less than two strands of fiber and a set of modern 100/200/400GbE coherent DWDM system line terminals. saying that the throughput of all of the ka-band spot beams on a satellite is 1Tbps is both double-counting math for the capacity in both directions, and does not reflect the actual capability of the satellite. maybe if every single ground station was something large enough and with enough link budget to operate at 16APSK and better modulations. not a realistic figure if you're talking about low-cost, sub $1500 hardware, consumer grade ku and ka band vsats. for a randomly chosen rural zip code in WA state, hughesnet is offering a 50GB quota/month for $150/month. so yes, 60GB transfer limits and things are still a real thing. and during peak evening hours TDMA contention means that latency will be 1150ms+, or worse. the unavoidable economics of consumer grade small VSAT require serious oversubscription. Dedicated 1:1 satellite capacity starts from $1500/Mbps and up, and requires a serious VSAT terminal, not a hughesnet/viasat/wildblue type toy. as to your last paragraph, if you have a proper 4G/LTE network in your area, just use that. There's verizon and at&t resellers with plans available that have quotas close to 200GB/month for a reasonable price now. why you would want a hybrid cheap vsat and 4G LTE setup, as a consumer, I don't know.