3 ms·
you sound like you have some expertise on this, so I would like your opinion on the following: on my street they have put up signs that display how many seconds
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
you sound like you have some expertise on this, so I would like your opinion on the following: on my street they have put up signs that display how many seconds it is to the light shift at the cross walk, ostensibly for bikes, but totally readable by cars - it's about 4 houses to the light. It struck me as being idiotic and wasteful for the environment to have made this sign and to use the electricity to power it, but also I would think there would be side effects to the traffic flow that would actually make the sign counterproductive - do you know what the usefulness of these signs is?
- tsjq 6y agoThe timer display is to keep people relaxed and to reduce unnecessary revving the throttle due to impatience while waiting for the red to turn green.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoOk, but it really looks like it is placed for the benefit of cyclists coming down the hill of the street. Also it is far enough back that when you are waiting for it to turn green you can't see it.
- cseleborg 6y agoDoesn't answer your questions, but this reminds me of the traffic lights in india that reset the counter when car drivers honk too much :-) https://edition.cnn.com/2020/02/05/india/mumbai-traffic-lights-tests-scli-intl/index.htm https://edition.cnn.com/2020/02/05/india/mumbai-traffic-ligh...
- bryanrasmussen 6y agodamn, I would like to put one of those in Naples, but I guess Neapolitan drivers aren't much for stopping at lights anyway.
- frosted-flakes 6y agoYour link returns a Not Found error for me.
- toast0 6y agoI'm just an observant amatuer, no professional traffic experience, although, someone linked a manual for LA's traffic management system (it's a commercial system, but the manual is customized for LA), and reading through some of that confirmed the observations of capability I've made over time. I haven't seen a time until green? (or is time until yellow/red?) sign like that personally, so I'm not sure about usefulness. I'd imagine electricity cost is pretty negligible, assuming LED lighting etc. I used to drive frequently in areas with countdown timers for pedestrian cycles; if the vehicle cycle was also ending, the vehicle light would turn yellow when the pedestrian signal hit zero. As a driver in the opposing direction, seeing the countdown helped me decide if I wanted to wait for the signal or make a right turn on red (if conditions permitted). As a driver in the direction of the countdown, it let me plan for a yellow, and I think I was able to make better decisions about stopping or going on yellow; I imagine some drivers might take the countdowns as a queue to speedup to make the light, anecdotally I didn't see that, but you'd need real numbers to decide. Anyway, if the approach to the intersection is a downhill, as a cyclist, it's nice to know earlier if I need to brake or not, or if I could make it through if I pedal a bit. If there's enough bike traffic to support that, it sounds nice. I don't think you could signal to bikes and not cars --- at least where I've riden, bicycles at reasonable speed are vehicles and should travel in vehicular lanes unless a restricted lane is available and appropriate (bike lanes are restricted to bikes, but bikes are not restricted to bike lanes). Given that, I don't know how you'd signal to cyclists and not car drivers.