4 ms·
> The problem with California's proposition system is that any modification to a proposition requires another direct-democracy vote to modify it in any way. Th
by skissane 6y ago
> The problem with California's proposition system is that any modification to a proposition requires another direct-democracy vote to modify it in any way.
That's not entirely true. The norm is that amending either an initiative statute or a constitutional amendment requires a further referendum. However, in the case of initiative statutes, it is possible for the text of the initiative statute to grant the Legislature the power to amend the statute without a further referendum. Indeed, if you look at the text of 1986's Proposition 65, section 7 provides the California Legislature the right to amend the proposition without a further referendum, provided that (a) the amendment furthers the purpose of the proposition (as given in section 1) and (b) the amendment is passed by a two-thirds vote in each house. (It also requires the Governor's signature, but a two-thirds vote is a veto-proof majority anyway.) And, in actual fact, the California Legislature has used this power at least once, in 2003, to amend the Proposition 65 text without further public vote.
(If there was any controversy about whether an amendment, passed by two-thirds vote in each house, met the requirement to "further the purpose" of Proposition 65, that would be a matter for the Supreme Court of California to determine.)
- epistasis 6y agoEven with your example, I'd say it's still strictly true that a proposition can not be modified without another direct democratic vote. In your example, even as the legislature performs legislation and the proposition allows, the proposition is unchanged and unchangeable by the legislature. And the cases where a proposition can be meaningfully changed or adjusted by the legislature is vanishingly small.
- skissane 6y ago> In your example, even as the legislature performs legislation and the proposition allows, the proposition is unchanged and unchangeable by the legislature. California Constitution, Article II section 10(c) says "The Legislature may amend or repeal a referendum statute. The Legislature may amend or repeal an initiative statute by another statute that becomes effective only when approved by the electors unless the initiative statute permits amendment or repeal without the electors’ approval" [1] So California's constitution is very clear, the Legislature can amend and repeal initiative statutes (of which 1986 Proposition 65 was one). The only question is whether the Legislature's amending/repealing legislation needs approval by the voters at the next election to become effective, and that question is determined by the text of the initiative statute itself. 1986 Proposition 65 imposes a two-thirds majority requirement and a requirement that the amendment further the same purposes in order to skip another public vote; other initiative statutes have different requirements, yet others require another vote for all amendments. [1] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=SEC.+10.&lawCode=CONS&article=II https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...