6 ms·
I think the article might not be doing a good job explaining the case because this doesn’t exactly sound like wrongdoing to me: “... looking to disadvantage ri
by Waterluvian 6y ago
I think the article might not be doing a good job explaining the case because this doesn’t exactly sound like wrongdoing to me:
“... looking to disadvantage rivals such as Microsoft’s Bing by depriving them of the data about users and user preferences that they need...”
Anyone care to sum up the argument?
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoWe won't know what the arguments are until the lawsuit is actually filed, or until it leaks. We don't even know what laws Google are alleged to have broken, nor what remedy the government seeks. And one thing we for sure won't know for a long, long time is whether they'll be able to make anything stick.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoI think a big part of this case is actually going to be the PR challenge of breaking up monopolies when there are so many moneyed individuals currently profiting from that monopoly's expansion. People don't dream of building their own livelihood anymore, most employees of tech companies these days just want their company to be consumed by another, bigger company so they can GTFO. This kind of short term thinking is actually bad for the economy and bad for customers because it leads to the proliferation of pump-and-dump businesses which exist solely for the purpose of being bought and sold rather than actually providing some kind of utility to the customer. This can have real consequences, such as how Arlo purports to be a "security company" to which people should entrust their safety despite the fact that their interface is so dysfunctional it would be a small miracle if any of their customers could actually figure out how to use their arlo footage in court. I know this because I spent the last summer running a small surveillance operation, and doing so required an off-site file server with high speed internet and a few python scripts to glue all the pieces together. And to anyone thinking "well if it doesnt provide utility it wouldn't get bought" you can hold your tongue because I don't believe that. That's an irrational argument. Useless, low quality goods and services make a killing on the market and we all know it. Anyone who has taken a real close look at any "smart" device certainly knows it.
- minot 6y agoon the flip side, I believe I read on a different thread how Amazon.com acquiring ring (the webcam doorbell company) was scary because Amazon.com had all the cards not the least of all was market information about ring and it's competitors. A lot of searches just begin and end on Amazon.com simply because we have prime and we don't understand how sunk cost works. I'm sure Google isn't 100% clean but I'd have hoped for attention to be on Amazon.com What's funny is that ring or nest or anyone else clearly has all the security issues above not to mention all these devices are just garbage if they can't connect to the Internet or if the server dies.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoI think getting a conviction is going to be the main issue given current us antitrust laws.
- ignostic 6y agoLong story short, Google is using its search dominance to provide unfair advantage to other Google and Alphabet products. This is primarily done through features or "snippets" competitors cannot earn or even pay for. Many of the details are not yet public. The individual investigations (some being conducted by states) are said to focus on multiple issues, but the one with the most discussion and evidence centers on the issue I described. For example, google a flight you may take regularly, or just "LAX to JFK". Your first result after ads will probably be a Google widget. Can sites like Kayak or Expedia get that widget? No. Can they compete with Google showing real-time prices right in the SERP? No. It's the definition of anti-competitive behavior. Google originally argued they don't advantage their own products. They've since admitted they do. Meanwhile they company is moving into more and more verticles and squeezing others out using its search engine as the weapon. The vast majority of qualified traffic comes from search engines, and for my sites it's more like 95-97% Google. Many have argued the 90% market share figure is too low, because Yahoo and Microsoft include their internal searches to sound better. If Google decides to create a search widget competing with some function of my site, even if Google's version is really shitty, my business suffers badly. This isn't theoretical. Go Google "speed test." Your first result is a Google widget they added to search results. Ookla IMO has a much better product. But Google's widget is first for basically everyone who searches for a speed test. The M-Lab/Google test caps out for me well short of my real bandwidth. But I guarantee Ookla's traffic took a beating when Google decided to insert their own product at the top. Unfortunately, Google has a lot of lawyers, and it's also reported that Barr is trying to rush this thing forward to provide a win for Trump. The actual career lawyers are arguing they can build a solid case, but they need more time. My fear is we'll see this thing rushed through and the changes will be cosmetic. And I do think Google's actions are a real problem. The most recent testimony before congress was pretty shocking. Facebook and Alphabet execs were basically admitting to anti-competitive behavior.
- visarga 6y ago"LAX to JFK" - at the top, after 3 ads, I see links to Expedia, Orbitz, Kayak, Travelocity and Skyscanner. Then comes the flights widget. Then Expedia direct link, another widget - this time a COVID alert for how many flights are still operating this route - quite useful and well placed. After that many more direct links. I don't see anything wrong. It's a good response page. If they didn't provide the widget the page would be worse, I would have to dig through all the links and filter the noise to find information. There's an assumption that people come to Google in order to find websites. No, they come for information. They can get information in many ways. People are not there just to provide sales to organically ranked sites. In a few years voice interfaces will probably replace text for search. In a voice interface, you have to provide the answer directly in plain language, not a link to a website. What would the displaced websites do, sue for monopolistic practices again?