5 ms·
This is why I see capitalism eventually failing. On one hand, I think it's great that these mind-numbingly boring jobs can be automated away. On the other hand,
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
This is why I see capitalism eventually failing. On one hand, I think it's great that these mind-numbingly boring jobs can be automated away. On the other hand, the end result is that more profits go to Amazon, while many more people have fewer opportunities to participate in the economy. For the old predictable arguments of "Well, these people can do something else, do you expect buggy whip makers to still be around?" - at some point if the rate of automation is faster than people are able to retrain, and faster than the economy is able to create new opportunities for these people, the outcome is still the same: all the benefits of capitalism go to very few people while huge swaths of people are made "redundant".
- throwawaysea 6y agoIs that a failure of capitalism or of our education systems or simply an oversupply of humans?
- TeaDrunk 6y agoAn oversupply of humans?
- ci5er 6y agoWell, we do replicate. Maybe not as much as rabbits. And, recently, we die less in childbirth and infant-hood. So - even with falling childbirth rates, we still tend to multiply a bit. But given that absolute and relative global poverty rates and starvation rates and disease mortality rates have plummeted and population grows dramatically - it becomes a resource allocation problem. Germany (for example) needs more laborers because of plummeting domestic birth rates. The retired community's social net requires young tax-payers to pick up the burden. Demographics are screwing with this math. Somalia or Syria (for example) have a lot of folks that need to escape. Problem: Once Turks or Arabs or Persians or Somalians or Syrians or Northern Africans get to Germany - they may or may not want to learn the language - but as refugees, they get full public benefit. And are not willing to learn or work to support retired Germans (this is an isolated example). Maybe we have an exploding population in all the wrong places? (I am not recommending genocide - just: It is a wicked problem)
- Barrin92 6y agowell given that Capitalism also increasingly optimises the education sector in the way it optimises conveyor belts it arguably is. In all of these discussions about automation, Capitalism, economic dynamics and so on a lot of people seem to try to argue that the process can be divided into the automation part, call it capitalism with a small c, and the education/political/human part, when in reality, technological process changes both in the exact same way. I mean even the term you went with "oversupply of humans", from which vantage point does such a label come? Sounds more like a rogue AI than a humanistic consideration. That would be Capitalism with a capital C speaking, I guess.
- halfmatthalfcat 6y agoThat’s why we have a government, to adapt society to an ever changing world. You can postulate as to _if_ government will step in an enact the requisite policies (UBI, Retraining, ect) but it doesn’t take a big imagination to see a world post-automation. There’s even a whole TV series set in such a world: Star Trek.
- NegativeLatency 6y agoSure would be cool if we could skip the whole dystopian bit, and the WWIII part, and the genetically engineered people rebellion.
- ci5er 6y agoThe nature of government is reactive, not pro-active. Except when they are stepping forward to propose a solution that won't work for a problem that doesn't exist for virtue/positioning points. Star Trek is a great fantasy, but we are a long ways away from that. (Culturally, politically, legally, technologically and economically)
- brnt 6y ago> The nature of government is reactive, not pro-active. What a nonsensical thing to say. There are so many counterexamples, where to even begin? Don't confuse your current administration or administrative culture for 'government' worldwide, throughout history.
- reaperducer 6y agoThe response to this is usually, "Well, then people should be retrained." It's kind of an elitist, SV bubble trope at this point. There are millions of people who simply cannot be retrained. Yes, pick-and-pack is mind-numbingly boring for many people. But for others, it's good. Or even challenging. I've worked on an assembly line three times in my life. I found it tedious and pointless, and to keep my mind busy, I mostly just focused on what I was going to do after work. But there were people there for whom the work was a perfect fit. Not everyone has the intellectual capacity of a SV keyboard jockey. Not everyone has average motor skills. These people still need jobs. Still need to earn money. Still have the right to participate in society. The solution is not to just throw UBI money at them and warehouse them in apartments like cattle. The solution is to automate an appropriate amount of factory jobs, but also keep an appropriate amount of low-skill jobs so that these people can be part of society.
- djsumdog 6y agoI think we'll see more low/mid scaled jobs. Capitalism is about continually innovating. The problems of course, are the finite set of resources, and the fact that you can't have infinite growth. We need to businesses around reuse and recycling. We need a ton of people who can find new ways to disassemble and dismal complicated parts, quickly, so they can be turned into new resources; so we're not shipping all our e-waste to kids in Africa who get heavy metal poisoning for a little bit of copper or lead. There are lots of things that still need innovation. You throw UBI and people, and you won't get that. UBI would work if we didn't have resource scarcity. We do not have Star Trek style replicators. We are far from being scarcity free.
- Analemma_ 6y ago> It's kind of an elitist, SV bubble trope at this point. I agree with the "elitist" part but not the "SV" part. "Well, they'll just get retraining" has been the orthodox economist's standard dismissal of any and all concerns related to automation and/or globalization for decades, long before Silicon Valley became economically or culturally influential. In fact, SV is more likely to support UBI, which is still a handwavy way-too-hopeful solution, but it's a step in the right direction.
- 6y ago
- WalterSear 6y agoI don't see how any of that leads to the failure of capitalism: it is, and will continue to succeed at explicitly everything it set out to accomplish.
- mistermann 6y agoDoes capitalism (as opposed to capitalists) have goals?
- nobody9999 6y ago>all the benefits of capitalism go to very few people while huge swaths of people are made "redundant". While that's true, it's only true from a short to medium-term perspective. In the US at least (perhaps some folks from elsewhere can chime in on this), nearly 70% of GDP is consumer spending. As you automate away jobs, that leaves fewer people with money to spend. The very wealthy, while certainly able to consume vastly more than others, can't make up for this. Mostly because there's a limit on how many pairs of pants, skirts, socks, sofas, T-bone steaks, homes, cars, half-caf soy lattes, etc., etc., etc. that one person or household can reasonably use. If current trends continue, eventually there won't be enough demand to satisfy the levels of production over the long-term -- which will cause the economy to crash and burn. As such, creating incentives to raise wages, employ more people and encouraging real investment by the wealthiest, rather than incentivizing the hoarding of financial resources, could ensure a vibrant economy for the long-term -- with benefits to everyone, including the very wealthy. Yes, it will mean that someone whose net worth could be hundreds of millions may only be tens of millions, but from the standpoint of living a good life, how would that make a material difference? Please note that I am emphatically not advocating for "forced wealth redistribution" or "nationalization of private industry." Rather, I'm suggesting that changing the incentives WRT wages, taxes and jobs in a capitalist system could have a profound positive effect in the near, medium and long-term on those with the least, and a profound positive effect on those with the most in the long-term. In fact, creating incentives to inject more consumer spending (through higher wages, incentives to innovate and engage in entrepreneurial activities, disincentives to using arbitrage and financial chicanery to increase wealth, etc.) is a market-based way to bolster the strength of the economy for the long-term, increase the consumer power of those with the least and ensure the long-term growth and stability of our economy and society. Let's do capitalism right and create a better world for all of us.