3 ms·
Some bloggers in the United States persist in blaming these outcomes on the ethnic diversity of the United States (ignoring the ethnic diversity of Singapore an
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Some bloggers in the United States persist in blaming these outcomes on the ethnic diversity of the United States (ignoring the ethnic diversity of Singapore and other countries that outperform the United States).
Which bloggers?
Incidentally, I think "ethnic diversity" is a red herring. Any bloggers who talk about "ethnic diversity" are merely trying to couch their conversation in PC language to avoid ad-hominem accusations of racism.
The issue is not "ethnic diversity". The issue is that certain ethnicities underperform. Specifically, African Americans and Hispanics (30% of the US, 0% of Singapore) underperform. Nonhispanic whites (about 65% of the US and close to 0% of Singapore) achieve mid-level performance. Asians (about 4% of the US and close to 100% of Singapore) overperform.
These effects are HUGE in comparison to inter-country effects. Asian Americans score about 10 pts below Singapore. The EU15 scores about 50 pts below Asian Americans, and a couple of points above All Americans.
http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2011/01/how-well-do-above-average-american.html http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2011/01/how-well-do-above-...
http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/12/amazing-truth-about-pisa-scores-usa.html http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/12/amazing-truth-abou...
It is simply incorrect to pretend that ethnic gaps in education do not exist, or to pretend that they do not explain a large portion of the gap between the US and the rest of the [edit: first] world.
Also, it would be helpful if you were a little more specific in your citations. Citing a gigantic PISA reports is much less useful than citing a specific table or figure. I'd love to learn more, but I don't have time to read the whole thing, and I have no idea which parts you are referring to.
[edit: wanted to clarify that I don't think the gaps between the US and poor locations, e.g., rural inland China or India, are primarily due to ethnicity. But gaps between wealthy first world countries do seem well explained by such factors.]
- kenjackson 16y agoUnfortunately, you can't disaggregate in the way suggested above. Blacks and Hispanics are also far less wealthy than whites in this country (which has a larger impact than even income). Once you control for wealth a lot of the gap disappears. Ethnic gaps may exist, but they probably are symptomatic of gaps in wealth more than anything else. But who konws. There are so many other factors at play for people of darker skin in general in society that I'd hesitate to subscribe to one theory. With that said, it does point to the fact that US public schools are probably better than most believe them to be.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoOnce you control for wealth a lot of the gap disappears. I haven't looked at it extensively, but I don't believe this is true. This study shows that SES (Socio Economic Status) doesn't explain much of the gap. http://www.umich.edu/~rdytolrn/pathwaysconference/presentations/craig.pdf http://www.umich.edu/~rdytolrn/pathwaysconference/presentati... This study (sorry, can't find a non-paywall version) shows that even holding income constant, blacks do worse than whites at the college level. In particular, low income whites perform as well as high income blacks. http://www.jstor.org/pss/2963200 http://www.jstor.org/pss/2963200 Also, even if you could explain the Black/white income gap via wealth, racism or other environmental factors, how would you explain the White/Asian gap? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Personal_income_race.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Personal_income_race.png And how would you explain that in spite of wildly different environmental factors (compare Singapore to Texas), there is a relatively small gap between Asian Americans and Asians? And similarly, there is only a small gap between white Americans and white Europeans? (By the way, I'm not trying to claim there are no other factors at play. I'm just pointing out that race does seem to be a biggie.)
- kenjackson 16y agoThe study you note focuses on income. There's another branch of research that focuses on wealth that shows that wealth is more important than income when it comes to things like college attendance. See: http://collegepuzzle.stanford.edu/?p=1590 http://collegepuzzle.stanford.edu/?p=1590 "“The Differential Impact of Wealth vs. Income in the College-Going Process” finds that wealth and income affect the college choice process differently, with wealth consistently being more significant in predicting who enrolls in college, and the type of college they attend – even after controlling for student differences in academic achievement, habitus, social capital, and cultural capital." More research clearly needs to be done here, but from what I've seen its clear that wealth looks to dominate income. And don't get me wrong, I'm not saying there aren't other differences. In fact I suspect there are societal and cultural differences that will manifest in one way or another. If you spend a lot of time in Asian households in the US, you'll see they often resemble, culturally, canonical Asian homes more than "US" homes. And there's data about the success of African immigrants to the US. Who often don't come wealthy (although some are), obviously are Black, but still do well. So there's clearly a culture issue here too, but I don't think we can really tease this apart without more data.