3 ms·
I've been using fish for a long time from the 1.x branch, after a long time using bash, and tcsh before that in the 90's. Before that the primitive CMD and DOS
by mixmastamyk 6y ago
I've been using fish for a long time from the 1.x branch, after a long time using bash, and tcsh before that in the 90's. Before that the primitive CMD and DOS.
I like much of what the new crew (who took it over) have done, but after installing it on a new machine recently I realized I didn't like their web configuration and some defaults. Which I almost never use, but a newbie would.
First, terminals have much improved in the last three decades. There's no obvious reason a curses-like app couldn't take the place of the web app. Configuring the shell from the web is rather gratuitous and weird IMHO.
A second, minor concern is the use of blue hues in their syntax highlighting defaults. Blue on black is rather unreadable, hard to see on its own, weakest of the colors due to eye sensitivity. It's also bad at night-time. I'd like to see a more neutral/warmer color palette for the default.
I have other nitpicks, such as their docs are not good enough on how all the types of variables work, and why you pick one or the other, for example. They moved away from the daemon, and variables no longer get propagated across shells. That was a neat feature but they removed it around the time they instituted the web server. I don't really get those design choices, but there's still no friendlier shell.
- mattgreenrocks 6y ago> They moved away from the daemon, and variables no longer get propagated across shells. Universal variable changes should be propagated across different fish processes. However, it looks like the maintainers are questioning whether they should live on.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoI had just tried it and it didn't work. But looking at the help, it needs a -U not a -u, thanks.
- ridiculous_fish 6y agofish-shell dev here. Sounds like you have been using it longer than me! We'd love to do a curses version of fish_config. I think you're right the default colors could be warmer and still work on light backgrounds (terminals don't publish their colors so the defaults have to work on light and dark). Variables are still instantly propagated, it just uses fifos instead of a daemon!
- mixmastamyk 6y ago> (terminals don't publish their colors so the defaults have to work on light and dark) Hi. There are actually some possibilities there, but it is not entirely reliable. Examples are xterm sequences and the COLORFGBG environment variable. Some terminals can be assumed to be dark such as the linux/bsd console or now vintage hardware. Windows is most often dark, but there is an API to ask as well. However, I don't think fish works there. Perhaps from LSW. Sounds like having default colors closer to medium gray is easier.
- co_dh 6y agoThe web configuration bring in a hell lot of dependencies. Please make it a separate project. Also if the readline part can be extracted to a separate executable, then it will be amazing. Imagine a fish like completion with psql.
- zanchey 6y agoThe only dependency the web configuration tool should bring in is Python, which is already an optional dependency for the manual page completion generator. You can install and run fish without ever running the web configuration.