2 ms·
> Because money is limited and those routes lose money. The money problem is in large part lack of money for capital expenditures, which Amtrak wouldn't have w
by jcranmer 6y ago
> Because money is limited and those routes lose money.
The money problem is in large part lack of money for capital expenditures, which Amtrak wouldn't have with a pure-NEC system anyways. The capital expenditure is going to have to come from Congress, and it's a lot easier to beg money from Congress if it isn't seen as purely benefiting rich coastal leftist elites.
> While we can (many do) debate what route to run new rails, what is the most important step to take first, and many other details, the big picture is the same to all observers.
Having read several transit enthusiast blogs, I will assure you that the big picture is not the same to all observers. The viewpoint of most enthusiasts tends to boil down to "just build something and people will get excited about it," whereas people like Alon Levy have instead argued that the real issue is that the US is relying on a century-old mindset of how to run trains and somewhere between ignorant and irrationally dismissive of how foreign countries run their superior modern rail systems.
- bluGill 6y agoIt may well be that I only read things from the Alon Levy bubble, and so I discount the rare times I come across something else as a crackpot and don't look for others in that bubble... This wouldn't be surprising, Alon Levy has good arguments as to why he is right (and has changed my mind a few times), while the others are obviously not living in reality.