5 ms·
“Sparc takes advantage of a newer electromagnet technology that uses so-called high temperature superconductors that can produce a much higher magnetic field, D
by Someone 6y ago
“Sparc takes advantage of a newer electromagnet technology that uses so-called high temperature superconductors that can produce a much higher magnetic field, Dr. Greenwald said. As a result, the plasma is much smaller.”
So, is this ‘just’ a matter of ITER being obsoleted by improvements in magnet tech before it is completed, or is there more in this design than scaling down ITER?
- vilhelm_s 6y agoI think at least the sales pitch is that the new magnets is all you need, and apart from that it uses the same well-understood technology that ITER is based around. https://www.psfc.mit.edu/files/psfc/imce/research/topics/sparc/MITSPARCbrochure.pdf https://www.psfc.mit.edu/files/psfc/imce/research/topics/spa...
- magicalhippo 6y agoThere's some discussion about this in this[1] presentation which also mentions the SPARC reactor. My main takeaway is basically yes, high-temp superconductors got "mainstream" very quickly. I'd recommend watching the whole thing, I found it quite interesting. [1]: https://youtu.be/L0KuAx1COEk?t=2929 https://youtu.be/L0KuAx1COEk?t=2929
- willis936 6y agoIt’s important to keep in mind that MIT is working hard to monetize HTS coil production. There are some unseen hush hush politics at play here.
- tsomctl 6y agoITER isn't meant to be a practical design, it's for research. So it's not obsolete just because it's using inefficient magnets.
- avmich 6y agoIt could be argued that ITER is actually quite important in learning how to deal with high technical complexity in general. Probably a good reason by itself to keep working on ITER, ISS is way simpler in comparison. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER#Criticism "The project however was significantly delayed at the design stage as result of purposeful decision to decentralize its design and manufacturing among 35 participating states, which resulted in complexity that was unprecedented but consistent with the initial ITER goals of creating knowledge and expertise rather than merely producing energy."
- mlindner 6y agoIn other words, ITER is a jobs project.
- knowaveragejoe 6y agoYou make it sound like it's a handout and a bad thing. IMO jobs facilitating knowledge, experience & wisdom transfer between so many countries is worthwhile on its own, nevermind that the goal is to help solve our energy problems. If we get experience developing a massive international moonshot program from a jobs program, so be it.
- baq 6y agojobs == domain knowledge
- Someone 6y agoThe article claims this design can easily be built before ITER is completed (5 years vs 15 years) It also says it can be built much cheaper than the total cost for ITER. The article doesn’t say it, but I would guess that it also can be built for less money than the money needed to complete ITER. If so, what’s not obsolete about ITER? Are there useful experiments that can be done with it that one can’t do with a more modern design?
- willis936 6y agoITER is much more complicated than SPARC. For example, the disruption mitigation system is similar to DIII-D's but with (I believe) much higher resolution in time and space. ITER has 80 MW of plasma heating but most Q targets only require ~50 MW. It is a platform to do science. It's a huge machine that is meant to demonstrate a tokamak reactor. Corners can't be cut to get there. Making a tiny machine quickly, skimming over the hard engineering problems is more of a moonshot approach. It's halfway to a startup with actual MIT startups selling HTS coils. Be wary of anyone selling something.
- pdonis 6y agoThe arxiv paper describing the design concept is here: https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.3540 https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.3540 Some additional features (besides the magnets) that jump out at me: The reactor vessel has joints to allow it to open up for maintenance access (previous tokamak designs have a reactor vessel that cannot be opened up once constructed, so maintenance inside has to be done through small access ports using remote manipulators). The external current drive for heating the plasma to ignition looks like it is more efficient than previous designs. The blanket around the reactor vessel is liquid instead of solid, using a fluorine-lithium-beryllium compound.
- pfdietz 6y agoAlso note from this paper: The power density of the reactor is 0.5 MW/m^3, which is 1/40th the power density of a commercial PWR primary reactor vessel. The reactor (a single one!) uses something like 40% of the world's current annual production of beryllium. If all the world's estimated resource of Be is used to make these reactors, it would be enough for reactors producing just 1% of world primary energy demand.
- beervirus 6y ago> The reactor (a single one!) uses something like 40% of the world's current annual production of beryllium. If all the world's estimated resource of Be is used to make these reactors, it would be enough for reactors producing just 1% of world primary energy demand. That's crazy. I guess if the design works out we can start casting about for a beryllium replacement.
- pfdietz 6y agoBeryllium has long been known to be problematic for fusion reactor walls, to be used sparingly if at all. Even lead (!) may have resource issues for widespread use of fusion.
- Stevvo 6y agoYou would still want to use remote manipulators even if you can open the reactor. The problem is not "small ports", it's that parts of the reactor vessel itself become irradiated. People can and have easily fit through the ports on JET, and will be able to on ITER. The remote manipulators are an amazing piece of technology; having the movements of your arms and hands replicated exactly by a robot is mind-blowing.
- DesiLurker 6y agoyes thats true. ITER is obsolete already because it actually cannot use these high-temp-high-Tesla superconductors. at the moment ITERs best hope is that it 'proves' that fusion is viable & then do a full redesign for DEMO to do proper scaled operation. here is the original presentation by Dr Whyte of MIT behind this Sparc project: https://youtu.be/KkpqA8yG9T4?t=1511 https://youtu.be/KkpqA8yG9T4?t=1511 he talks about the impact of these newer magnets at around 26min mark.