5 ms·
Speed is comparatively easy for electric propulsion -- on land (Tesla) or air (here). Range is quite another issue. A Cesna 172 has a 1,289 km range, four tim
by dredmorbius 6y ago
Speed is comparatively easy for electric propulsion -- on land (Tesla) or air (here).
Range is quite another issue. A Cesna 172 has a 1,289 km range, four times the Rolls-Royce prototype, and carries more than just the piolot and fuel.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_172#Specifications_(172R) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_172#Specifications_(172...
For both land and air, total payload is another hard limit. Tesla achieves admirable results for a passenger vehicle by using high energy/volume and energy/mass batteries integrated into the vehicle structure itself. Battery EV trucks have had range limits of measured in single-digit kilometers. Their fuel-based counterparts exceed four digits (1,000 km). Accellerating, decellerating, and managing mass costs joules.
- NovemberWhiskey 6y agoThe basic problem with electric aircraft vs. electric cars is that aircraft spend a much larger proportion of their journeys operating at high power levels. A slow, economy cruise setting in a Cessna 172 is a 45% power setting - ~80 hp, and climbs will be at full power (180 hp). On the other hand, you might only need ~20 hp to maintain 65mph on a level road in a sedan; and most people never use anything like the full power of their cars for more than seconds at a time.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThat, and the fact that fuel-powered aircraft will shed half their takeoff weight during flight. Battery-powered aircraft either maintain constant mass or gain mass in the case of metal-air batteries, as energy is discharged. Long-haul alt-energy aircraft utilise very low airspeed (low drag), extreme mass budgets (they're wonders of materials and structural engineering), and altitude profiles (potential energy0 to manage overall energy budgets and use.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> fuel-powered aircraft will shed half their takeoff weight during flight. While that is true of jets optimized for altitude, small piston aircraft (cessnas) do not burn nearly that much fuel on takeoff. Small aircraft can generally do a dozen or more takeoff/landing cycles on a single tank.
- nickff 6y agoFuel is burned throughout the flight, not just take-off (and initial climb to altitude), which is why airliners flying long-haul routes usually gain altitude as they progress. The Cessna 172 seems to have a fuel fraction of around 20% (an order of magnitude higher than a car), and airliners are much higher (~40%).[1][2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_172 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_172 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_fraction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_fraction
- dredmorbius 6y agoA 2020 Toyota Camry --- a typical 4-door sedan --- has a curb weight of 3,340 lb and a 15.8 gallon fuel tank (95 lb), for a fuel-to-weight ratio of 2.8%. Range is ~615 miles at 39 mpg highway. Passenger and cargo capacity is another 1,500 lb on top of this, give or take. This is far lower than any conventional aircraft, though a few ultralights might compare.
- TylerE 6y agoEven on a tiny little Cessna fuel is 1/8th of the weight, and fuel burn per hour in cruise is approx. 50lbs/hr.
- dredmorbius 6y agoAnd again with my Camry example, assuming 60 mph and 39 mpg, that's about 9 lb/hr fuel consumption. The Cesna has a 140 mph cruise, a bit over double that of the Camry on highway, but that still means 20 lb at equivalent distance for the car, less than half the light plane. Aircraft are fuel burners. (Agreeing, just giving land-travel equivalent.)
- namdnay 6y agoI think this depends where you're driving. If you're at 130kmh in a 70hp subcompact, something perfectly common in Europe, you're pretty close to max power..
- ovi256 6y agoA 70hp compact can't maintain 130kmph on a climbing highway, only on a flat highway. I know this from experience - I had to pull into the slow lane with the trucks. Plus, a compact car at full throttle is really an unpleasant experience - the car wheezes at high volume and you can feel it's doing its best and it's not enough.
- namdnay 6y agoAgreed. Which demonstrates that cars often do run at 80-100% of their capacity for long periods of time
- NovemberWhiskey 6y agoI don't think that demonstrates that at all, but even assuming it did: when they do so, they get diabolical gas mileage. Top Gear did an amusing test where they had a Toyota Prius drive flat out around a track, with a BMW M3 (a larger, heavier sports sedan) keeping pace with it. Over the course of the test, the Prius returned 14.3 miles per gallon; and the BMW M3 achieved 16.1 - despite the fact the BMW has a 4 liter turbocharged, six cylinder engine vs. the Prius 1.5 liter, four cylinder.
- namdnay 6y agoTo be fair, that test way way above legal speeds. I don't think it's representative even of motorway performance. I don't see your point however - what I'm saying is that at 130kmh (standard motorway speed in most of europe) a 70-90hp subcompact (by far the most common car in europe and the world in general) is running at above 80% max power (testified by the fact that as soon as there's a significant incline their speed will fall back to 110-120). So running long times under heavy engine load is quite normal for cars
- dexen 6y ago>aircraft spend a much larger proportion of their journeys operating at high power levels. Luckily the high power level is maintained at reliably high speed [0], ensuring airflow for cooling. Even better, aircraft by its very long-range nature will have much larger battery:engine ratio. For example this 2018 article [1] discusses airplane with 9x the Tesla's battery capacity and 3x the Tesla's engine power, in other words, its batteries would need to handle only 1/3rd electrical load as much at peak load (per unit). The lower power density[2] of the battery pack again provides for easier cooling; perhaps even passive cooling or air cooling instead of forced liquid cooling. Whereas Tesla's sustained performance is limited by battery pack thermals. Lastly, it's worth noting the ICE aircraft engines are "overbuilt" as compared to the roadgoing ones, mostly for sake of reliability. -- [0] aside of the engine run-up and initial acceleration, but both of those are short anyway [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18602771 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18602771 [2] not to mix it up with energy density
- nickik 6y agoElon solution for this is to go much higher then a typical plane. This is much more possible with electric and helps with efficiency. https://youtu.be/MBItc_QAUUM?t=2422 https://youtu.be/MBItc_QAUUM?t=2422
- eptcyka 6y agoGetting higher is no easy feat, especially given the energy density of the current state of the art batteries.
- dhsysusbsjsi 6y agoNot to mention additional complexities going above 10,000 ft that adds weight: pressurised cabin (or oxygen) and anti-ice and de-ice systems and heating.
- steffan 6y agoExceeding 10,000 ft. is orthogonal to needing anti-/de-ice systems. In fact, you're often less likely to need them at the higher altitudes because it is too cold for airframe icing to occur. Counterintuitively, if it is too cold, you no longer have icing problems.
- eptcyka 6y agoYou need to pass all of the feet leading up to 10'000 feet though.
- nickik 6y agoYou can use the batteries as structure and they produce heat that you need to cool anyway. Seems like there is a lot you can do with that once you start optimizing everything around the battery. I don't know how much weight a anti-ice/de-ice could add. My point was only that once you think about it and redesign everything around the new constraints, you can come up with things that we don't yet think about.
- 6y ago
- joncrane 6y ago>Accellerating, decellerating, and managing mass costs joules Ideally, aside from parasitic losses, shouldn't decelerating pay joules?
- dredmorbius 6y agoNet it's a loss compared to constant velocity. A few years ago an electric bus hypermiled to get some ludicrous range. Turns out the trial stripped all spare mass from the rig (seats, other interior), pumped tyres to munition-rated pressures, hugely oversized the battery, and held a constant speed of about 24 kph (15 mph). https://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-proterra-range-record-20170919-story.html https://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-proterra-ran... (The article, as with most, reveals no test conditions though does at least note "a Proterra spokeswoman said they won’t reveal the test bus speed".) In production, range claims seem to be about 1/3 this. Typical city busses stop every block or two, accelerating to about 40 kph, then braking, every 60 seconds or so. Both mileage and wear and tear suffer immensely.
- joncrane 6y agoI'm not sure this is true. I've been told that, for example, the "city" MPG of hybrid cars with regenerative braking is higher than the "highway" MPG. This is because it simply costs energy to maintain speed in the face of hills, wind resistance, and parasitic/rolling losses. However in "city" driving much of the energy is reclaimed through braking. A big part of this is wind resistance; as you know wind resistance increases with the square of the speed, so going 60MPH is going to cost quadruple what it costs to go 30MPH, and presumably "city" driving doesn't go much higher than 30 MPH.
- ggreer 6y ago> Battery EV trucks have had range limits of measured in single-digit kilometers. I don't believe you. Find me an EV truck that any company has fielded in the past 20 years that has less than 10km range. Also you're comparing a prototype to a mature technology. One might as well note that early automobiles had less range, lower speed, worse reliability, and higher cost than horses. And unlike horses, automobiles require infrastructure such as roads and gasoline stations. All of those things were true at the time, but horses couldn't be improved upon and automobiles could. Now we're in the same position with respect to gas vehicles vs electric vehicles. Battery technology is improving at an impressive rate. Energy density has doubled since 2010. Price per kilowatt-hour is 1/9th what it was a decade ago.[1][2] These advances have made EVs competitive on the ground. It's quite likely that improvements will continue and EVs will become competitive in the air. EVs have lower refueling costs, lower maintenance costs, and are simpler designs (making them cheaper and safer). We already have battery-powered commercial drones. Human flight is more conservative when it comes to adopting new technologies, so it'll probably take longer for EV planes to become widespread. But long term? I would bet on EV planes replacing regional jets. 1. https://cleantechnica.com/2020/02/19/bloombergnef-lithium-ion-battery-cell-densities-have-almost-tripled-since-2010/ https://cleantechnica.com/2020/02/19/bloombergnef-lithium-io... 2. https://www.statista.com/statistics/883118/global-lithium-ion-battery-pack-costs/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/883118/global-lithium-io...
- dredmorbius 6y agoBMW's Terberg YT202-EV electric tractor, tested~2015, comes to mind. Its route during trials was 2km, though the claimed range was 100 km. I strongly suspect the latter was slow and unloaded. Speed was restricted in any regard: BMW and the SCHERM Group have put a massive 40-ton EV into service for a one-year pilot. The Terberg YT202-EV electric tractor will travel a 2 km route eight times a day between the SCHERM group logistics center and the BMW plant in Munich, transporting vehicle components such as shock absorbers, springs and steering systems. The standard tractor has two batteries (112 kWh), and a third battery can be fitted for extended operations. It is equipped with a 138 kW, 720 N·m Siemens motor and an Allison 3000 transmission. Top speed is 25 mph. The YT202-EV has a range of up to 100 kilometers (62 miles), theoretically enough for a full production day. BMW says it will be charged exclusively with renewable electricity, and will save 11.8 tons of CO2 annually compared to a legacy diesel truck. https://chargedevs.com/newswire/bmw-tests-40-ton-electric-truck-for-materials-transport/ https://chargedevs.com/newswire/bmw-tests-40-ton-electric-tr...
- nickik 6y agoHere is Elon idea to 'fix' this issue. Some interesting ideas. https://youtu.be/MBItc_QAUUM?t=2422 https://youtu.be/MBItc_QAUUM?t=2422 - Going higher - Using gravitational energy on the second half/landing part of the journey. Like a car going down hill. - Making use of the higher power density of the engines - (Doesn't mention this, but using batteries as structural elements) I also think that this: "Prandtl Wing Minimum Drag Update" - Al Bowers (Chief Scientist at NASA) would be a key technology https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bCwtcDNB15E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bCwtcDNB15E A new type of wing and maybe more importantly a new type if turbine fan.
- gamblor956 6y agoSo basically Elon has suggested doing all the things they already do today to maximize fuel savings in ICE planes... Note that airplane fuel has significantly higher power density than an electric battery (~40x as much, see https://www.theverge.com/2018/8/14/17686706/electric-airplane-flying-car-battery-weight-green-energy-travel https://www.theverge.com/2018/8/14/17686706/electric-airplan...), so no EV will ever be able to achieve the same range as an ICE plane, ton-for-ton.
- nickik 6y ago> So basically Elon has suggested doing all the things they already do today to maximize fuel savings in ICE planes... No. If you think that you didn't get his point. - Fuel is not structural in a plane. Only fuel tanks. - ICE are only optimally efficent at a particular height. - ICE can not convert gravitational energy into fuel. - ICE vehicles have a lower power density and are bigger. Making it harder to gimbals them for VTOL. This is a cause of huge issues with military VTOL. > EV will ever be able to achieve the same range as an ICE plane, ton-for-ton And they don't have to to beat ICE in the market.
- gamblor956 6y ago1) If you want to get that technical, like fuel, battery cells aren't structural either. The battery casings like the fuel tank shells, are the structural components that can be used as structural elements. And on some planes, they are used in that manner for weight-saving. 2) Irrelevant. They're still more efficient than EV planes at any height, so comparing the relative efficiency of ICE to itself is pointless. 3) Neither can EV planes, unless someone has discovered how to turn gravity into electricity without water and a massive turbine. 4) ICE vehicles have higher power density (see previous Verge link, also https://www.topspeed.com/cars/warp-coils-seem-closer-to-reality-than-a-battery-with-energy-density-of-gasoline-ar185365.html https://www.topspeed.com/cars/warp-coils-seem-closer-to-real...). It's not even close. 43x-100x the power density of batteries, depending on the type of fuel and the type of battery. ICE vehicles are bigger because they are used to carry more things and people: hundreds of people or hundreds of tons of cargo on trips that can go almost halfway across the world without stopping. In contrast, an EV plane can currently carry itself, a pilot and a passenger, for almost long enough to get from LA to Fresno. (No EV currently on the market can even make the trip from LA to SF.) And they don't have to to beat ICE in the market. You're right. EVs will never be able to compete at the ranged market; they'll be limited to short-range hops. This means they won't be a viable option for the corporate/personal jet market beyond limited hobbyist use.
- Robotbeat 6y agoI mean, this plane is a sprinter. If you want range, use sailplane techniques and with similar chemistry as for terrestrial lithium ion you can get >1000km range with multiple passengers and speed just as high as high speed rail (or higher). Eviation Alice and other concepts show how this could be done. Just a matter of time and a LOT of effort. Battery EV trucks (lots of prototypes and maybe even low volume production going on, from Tesla to Daimler) regularly get multiple hundred kilometers of range and 1000km isn’t at all unreasonable although 500 miles is probably the sweet spot in the near term to avoid reducing available payload (any greater range has diminishing returns due to regulatory requirements for rest stops). And that’s without advanced chemistries that you can get now at low volumes like metal anode or lithium-sulfur which double the specific energy and allow double the range (to say nothing of lithium-air, which is easily over a decade away from practical use but would eliminate the disparity in useful specific energy between battery-electric and hydrocarbon combustion in almost all cases—rocketry and munitions being the major exception). EDIT: Daimler has delivered some 300-400km range electric Freightliner semis for customer testing already: https://electrek.co/2020/03/04/daimler-electric-freightliner-semi-trucks-ecascadia/ https://electrek.co/2020/03/04/daimler-electric-freightliner...
- alex_duf 6y agoI get what you are saying, but it's going to be hard to compete with the speed of a jet engine, with propellers or ducted fans. Unless I'm mistaken? Can ducted fans match the speed of a jet engine?
- barbegal 6y agoMost of the propulsion of a modern turbofan engine comes from the fan rather than the jet turbine so ducted fans can match the speed of a turbofan.
- xorcist 6y ago> Battery EV trucks have had range limits of measured in single-digit kilometers Battery powered trucks that you can buy today from the likes of Scania/Daimler has a range of 200+ km. Not some prototype but currently in production for delivery next year. Sure, it's not 1000 km, but that single digit km is off by two magnitudes.