3 ms·
Fast freight --- say, a unit train of coal or clinker at 110 * 200 tonne cars --- has kinetic energy at the square of speed, posing increased risks to the freig
by dredmorbius 6y ago
Fast freight --- say, a unit train of coal or clinker at 110 * 200 tonne cars --- has kinetic energy at the square of speed, posing increased risks to the freight service itself, any shared-road or adjacent-road traffic, level crossings, and structures, property, or natural features boardering tracks, as well as wear and tear on track and rolling stock. These are part of those safety standards you note, among other factors.
High-speed rail demands fully separated rights of way for reasons of route and destination, safety, predictable scheduling, minimum turning radius, and more. Unfortunately in a world of strong land-property rights and interests, this makes it extraordinarily politically vulnerable.
A few years ago I realised that virtually every successful large-scale rail system (both high-speed and earlier "conventional" services) emerged in a largely uncontested land-rights regime. For the 19th century US and British systems, a pre-industrial or pioneer domain in which land owners were few, poor, or both. On completion, the US transcontinental railroad was seen as a boondoggle "road to nowhere", though various "wheres" began springing up along its route nearly immediately.
(Famously, Denver, Colorado, saw a 10x population growth in the decade after a spur line was built to the transcontinental route.)
For Japan and Europe, planning for high-speed fail began following the physical and economic devastation of WWII. Landholders couldn't put up much of a fight.
China's HSR growth resembles that of frontier America and early-industrial Britain, benefitting by a different land-ownership regime.
The most pernicious obstacle to California high-speed rail is Atherton.