7 ms·
On a meta level, this is one of the reasons why I tell every junior/entry level person I encounter in the ISP business the following: Ethics is important in net
by walrus01 6y ago
On a meta level, this is one of the reasons why I tell every junior/entry level person I encounter in the ISP business the following: Ethics is important in network engineering. You can and should refuse to do things that cause measurable harm to the Internet. You should understand why certain things are bad, and should make a conscious choice not to aid and abet them.
It is regretful that organizations like NANOG, RIPE, ARIN, APNIC and others do not take a stronger stance (on a global geopolitical level) against censorship of the Internet, and attempts to create walled gardens and national firewalls.
The people who possess the equivalent of 'enable'/'configure' on the core routers of gigantic ASNs have real power to refuse to further harm the Internet.
We have seen a number of discussions on HN about ethics in software engineering. A quick search for posts with 'ethics' in the subject line turns up a number of things. In my opinion, ethics in the ISP, telecom and network engineering industry is equally important.
- jacquesm 6y agoThis goes for any position with responsibility for and access to end user data. For instance: administering a mail server or hosted mail account for the company, dealing with the fall-out of security incidents and so on.
- joosters 6y agoAll well and good, but are these kind of 'middleboxes' unequivocally unethical? For example, some ISPs might want to block highly illegal content - let's use the typical examples, e.g. child porn sites, malware domains, and so on. It's not inherently unethical (or, at least, there are plenty of reasonable people who would say it is ethical) to install a middlebox that will make it more difficult for users to access these sites. So now your company has got a content blocker installed. What exactly are your network engineers meant to do now? Demand personal refusal over any additions to the sites that these boxes will block? That seems highly unlikely to happen, and how could that even work in practice? Are all the engineers meant to vote on blocks, and only those unopposed sites get added to the list? Can ethical network engineers usefully oppose content blocking?
- walrus01 6y ago> let's use the typical examples, e.g. child porn sites, malware domains a futile game of whack-a-mole that only serves to make politicians feel good, and so they can claim they're "doing something" about social threats. malware domains can be adequately addressed at the application level through things such as: https://www.google.com/search?channel=fs&client=ubuntu&q=google+safe+browsing+api+malware+domain https://www.google.com/search?channel=fs&client=ubuntu&q=goo...
- joosters 6y agoDevil's advocate response: If these content blockers are just 'futile games of whack-a-mole', then why are you getting up-in-arms about their existence? Should be easy to avoid them if you truly believe what you say.
- walrus01 6y agoStuff like what the UK is trying to do with a DNS based "black list" of bad things on the internet? Futile game of whack a mole. Authoritarian regime that forces all ISPs in a country to run networks funnelling all traffic through a government run central point where they do DPI and flow analysis on it (Chinese GFW for instance)? More of a real threat. For instance there is one ASN in Iran that has transit connections to the outside world. All ISPs are forced to be downstream of it. https://bgp.he.net/AS12880 https://bgp.he.net/AS12880
- joosters 6y agoWell, yes, the original article is about funneling traffic through a centralised DPI content blocker, and not a trivial DNS blacklist. Agreed, the UK's DNS filtering is definitely a simple to defeat by anybody whack-a-mole (e.g. thepiratebay.org is blocked? Oh no! Let's just google for Pirate Bay and pick one of the many, many unblocked mirrors) But the kind of DPI, forced blocking utilised by these middleboxes is certainly a step above that, to the point that most people will not be (say) using measures like a VPN to bypass the block.
- kitteh 6y agoIt'd be nice if we could address some things like BCP38 (anti spoofing), RPKI, route filtering and folks who knowingly support infrastructure that's used for outbound ddos (c2s and regular hosts), spam and malware phishing. Plenty of hosting shops in US and Canada have these problems. That seems a bit more within our reach whereas an ISP in India is more than happy to pay a vendor to implement middlebox packet molesters.
- walrus01 6y agoAbsolutely agreed. It is really easy to be a shitty, lazy colocation/hosting/VPS hosting company. It is somewhat more effort and more difficult to be a proper one. Margins are so thin in the hosting business that it would be own version of a personal hell... I feel a lot better about operating symmetric gigabit last mile residential services.
- kitteh 6y agoYes. Many of these shops follow the same design patterns. Ports for hosts at L2 that they bill on that are part of a big Vlan/L3/SVI interface that has tons of customers. I've seen these configs where folks have hundreds of "secondary" ip addresses setup where any customer can steal other customer IPs in addition to lack of anti spoofing. It's slop and it's tolerated.
- ev1 6y agoI've been dealing with a ban evader/forum shock image spammer for months now, and the place he is buying proxies from is actively doing BGP hijacking on resources owned by AT&T, Windstream, hospitals and universities - for the primary purpose of carding and fraud. I haven't managed to get anyone knowledgeable at those companies to figure out how to pressure the small upstreams (that are not those T1s) to stop it.
- sroussey 6y agoGood luck. When I wrote forum software, moderation controls, what people might call shadow banning these days, and other filtering took up 70% development time. Retaliation was DDOS. I was one of Cloudflare’s first customers.
- foobiekr 6y agoThis is a great position. As someone who works in SP on the vendor side, I think it's great someone is carrying the torch.