4 ms·
>> which advocates stratification of society based on the birth Not a unique to Indian nationalism. American nationalism is very similar. See the "birther" m
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> which advocates stratification of society based on the birth
Not a unique to Indian nationalism. American nationalism is very similar. See the "birther" movement. Or the president's push to withdraw birthright citizenship, a concept that would deny far more than just education. Or the references to "anchor babies". The location of one's birthplace, and the birthplace of one's parents, is of fundamental importance in US nationalist movements just as in India.
- oytis 6y agoBirthright citizenship is pretty unique to America though. Nowhere in Europe you would find such a thing, although most people won't count Germany, France, Netherlands, Sweden etc. as human right violators.
- unishark 6y agoAlso Canada, Mexico, and almost all of South America. Only a few other countries elsewhere, none of them developed.
- baud147258 6y agoMaybe I missed something or forgot how citizenship works here in France (since I learned how it is acquired as a student), but birthright citizenship seems pretty similar to what we have here
- eli_gottlieb 6y agoFrance has a mixture of jus soli and jus sanguinis, like most countries. Pure jus soli, as in the American case, is in fact quite rare.
- oytis 6y agoJust checked the wiki, looks like France defines something called double jus soli, which means a person who was born in France to a parent who themselves is born in France (even though they might not be a French citizen) gets the citizenship. That's a bit closer to birthright citizenship that what we have in Germany, but nowhere as liberal as USA laws, which give citizenship to anyone born in the USA even if their parents entered the country one day before the birth and left next day after the birth. That is something that doesn't exist anywhere in Europe to my knowledge.
- baud147258 6y agoIt seems I didn't look closely enough at the details, thanks for the clarification
- C1sc0cat 6y agoIronic given that Donald Trumps grandfather was an immigrant - and German immigrants where subject to discrimination.
- lolcastevspres 6y agoIt's only ironic if you think castes are somehow equivalent to allowing the grandson of an immigrant to run a country. It's not ironic. It's not even relevant. This site sometimes and its weird desire to turn every discussion into one that is critical of the US or Trump. Yeah keep pressing the downvote button and I'll keep using carrier grade NAT to make new accounts. Fuck you anti American assholes.
- Eldt 6y agoI hope you get the help that you need.
- fetbaffe 6y agoHow is that ironic?
- C1sc0cat 6y agoNativists campaigned against incomers from Europe
- fetbaffe 6y agoSo basically you never become a native regardless how many generations you stay in a country, thus nationalism is valid point of view.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoI didn't say that :-) I was commenting on the use of nativism by a politician whose grandfather was an immigrant. Though over time some groups formerly seen as undesirables become honoury whites Irish German Catholics etc. It wasn't that long ago that having a catholic president Kennedy was seen as problematic
- lolcastevspres 6y agoLol comparing India's traditional caste system to the Constitution's requirement that the President be a natural born citizen -- the only role in our government like this -- is a real stretch. So is the birthright citizenship, something only common in the New World to begin with. Give me a break.