4 ms·
> Something might be a long standing practice and still be against the law. That's extremely unlikely -- it would have been prosecuted previously otherwise. A
by crazygringo 6y ago
> Something might be a long standing practice and still be against the law.
That's extremely unlikely -- it would have been prosecuted previously otherwise.
A better term for "long standing practice" is precedent. Laws often don't account for certain edge cases or unseen developments, so judges in common law countries do very much look at what other judges have permitted or not in the past, in order to maintain continuity.
Otherwise you'd be at the whim of each and every judge interpreting law totally differently, which would be a nightmare for anyone trying to figure out what is permitted or not.
- bart_spoon 6y ago> That's extremely unlikely -- it would have been prosecuted previously otherwise. This sounds like the legal equivalent of the joke about the two economists who find a $20 bill on the ground. One asks "Is that a $20 bill?" The other says, "Couldn't be. If it was, someone would have picked it up by now", and they move on.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIn some cases, an injustice goes long-standing because nobody bothers to litigate it. But the far more common scenario is that it's been litigated and the counter-argument found wanting.
- ponker 6y agoThe Emoluments Clause has been in open violation for 3.5 years and nothing has happened. Doesn't mean anything.
- crazygringo 6y agoI'm talking about law as applied to everyday citizens and corporations. When you get to balance of powers and prosecuting presidents, you're not really operating primarily in the legislative game anymore, but rather in the power politics game, no matter how much they dress it up in legal language.