3 ms·
I'm not sure people are aware, but most countries find Amnesty International annoying. My own country - Australia - has been frequently criticised by Amnesty (
by nl 6y ago
I'm not sure people are aware, but most countries find Amnesty International annoying.
My own country - Australia - has been frequently criticised by Amnesty (eg [1]).
Amnesty's job is to call out human right violations. Citizens of a country may very well say "oh, we don't like these asylum seekers, so we will keep voting for the government that put these laws in place" (in Australia's case). But it isn't Amnesty's job to look at justifications, only violations.
A robust, functional democracy should have space to allow critics, and while it might be unrealistic to expect the government to welcome that criticism, a government shouldn't use its power to act in reprisal against critics.
Some people in this discussion should consider this carefully. It's one thing to disagree with critics, but quite another to approve of reprisals against those critics.
[1] https://www.dw.com/en/australia-pm-rejects-amnesty-internationals-asylum-seeker-torture-claims/a-36072994 https://www.dw.com/en/australia-pm-rejects-amnesty-internati...
- liar_brigade 6y agoThis is true, but sadly, organizations that value and promote human rights are always going to be targeted right-wing extremists, as they are fundamentally opposed to this ideal. Especially true in India now that they have their own Hindu Hitler.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]