5 ms·
I completely reject the idea that college is a job training program. Making connections between a "career" and an undergraduate degree is exactly how we got wh
by mulmen 6y ago
I completely reject the idea that college is a job training program. Making connections between a "career" and an undergraduate degree is exactly how we got where we are today.
I'm in support of continuing education but I don't think it needs to be tied to jobs. People should continue learning and pursuing their interests for their whole lives.
If we want job training trade schools exist and do a great job.
- nickff 6y agoCollege isn't about job training, it's more about demonstrating that one is good prospective employee (signalling).[1] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Case_Against_Education#:~:text=The%20Case%20Against%20Education%3A%20Why%20the%20Education%20System,in%20labor%20economics.%20Caplan%20argues%20that%20the%20prima https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Case_Against_Education#:...
- andreev_io 6y agoPerhaps the more original source for this idea is in Michael Spence’s 1973 paper on Job Market Signaling: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_(economics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_(economics)
- swiley 6y agoReally? I remember half my capstone classmates that couldn't code or focus for more than five minutes on a project. All of them had good grades of course.
- throwawaysea 6y agoSure people should continue learning and pursuing their interests their whole lives. But why do taxpayers need to subsidize it? If someone has an interest in something as a hobby, they can finance it themselves.
- alextheparrot 6y agoEnrichment of the population can be beneficial and worth fostering? This doesn’t speak to if we should do it, just that there are reasons to argue for it.
- mulmen 6y agoI didn't say anything about funding education, just the reasoning for it. Having said that I do believe undergraduate education should be available to everyone. As automation continues to improve there is less and less need for labor. Why not reduce the supply a bit and get more educated citizens out of the deal? If we say an undergraduate education is not worth taxpayer dollars then the real question seems to be "how much education is enough?" If 16 years is too much how do we know 12 is the right amount? The question leaves open the possibility that 8 years is just as good. Clearly some amount of taxpayer funded education is beneficial. It seems natural to me that the ideal amount of education will continue to increase as we learn more as a species.
- caspper69 6y agoYou have a weird definition of the word "subsidize." I suppose I will allow low-income subsidies, but I consider non-dischargeable federal debt to be less of a subsidy and more of a "sure we'll help, but you better keep paying every f'ing month, or we'll make your life challenging, and we'll still get our money when you die," and less of a "here's some free government money with no strings attached." It's also an excellent way to "print" money and ensure a steady cash-flow. I guess it depends on which narrative makes you sleep at night with your worldview.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bnralt 6y agoPeople still pursue their own interests, but usually it's outside of a university setting. Mixing these things with job training and then siloing them into an expensive and overly bureaucratic[1] system called "college" is of questionable value. [1]Compare signing up for a college foreign language course with signing up for a foreign language course outside of college.