3 ms·
re Insulin: I did say insulin was a major component, I agree of course it's not the only component. > There's nothing really special about IF for fat loss, mus
by arcticbull 6y ago
re Insulin: I did say insulin was a major component, I agree of course it's not the only component.
> There's nothing really special about IF for fat loss, muscle gain, or for reducing insulin resistance. Improved insulin sensitivity is a natural result of fat loss.
I think it's too early to say that, which is why we need more studies. To your own point, there aren't enough. In no small part because there are so many different protocols and studies both mix-and-match protocols and also often use questionable ones. Sometimes "fasting" means eating a few hundred calories or a fasting-mimicking diet. Sometimes it means 16:8. Sometimes it means alternate-day. Sometimes it means 5 days on and 2 days off.
> It's also only a matter of time before you start losing muscle. Muscle protein breakdown rates starts in between 15-30 hrs of fasting[1].
For what it's worth, proteolysis does not imply the loss of muscle mass after re-feeding in short-term fasting. The working thesis is that while fasting your body attempts to spare as much muscle as possible (in part through HGH) and that protein breakdown slows dramatically [4].
After all, HGH increases fat oxidation and increases protein retention, so it would all make sense.
I didn't, and don't think that, fasting will increase muscle mass, but I have seen no evidence that it will, as you suggest, break down muscle in any meaningful way until far, far later in the starvation cycle. Muscle in particular is a fuel of last resort. Wouldn't make much sense otherwise. There will always be some turnover, of course.
> Resting Metabolic Rate
Studies show that during short-term fasting your metabolic rate stays pretty consistent, and increases over the first couple of days. A couple of studies pins it at up to +10% after 36-48 hours. [1,2] It doesn't actually drop until 60-96 hours into a fast. [3]
tl;dr: I guess my point is, it's too early to be dismissive. More data is needed.
> This suggests that 20+ hour fasts may negatively affect you muscle mass and fat loss.
I will say this particular line is kind of nuts, if you think about it. How can not eating anything at all slow down your fat loss when you have a caloric deficit of 2500kcal/day? That's why you have fat. That's why your body enters ketosis over the first 3 days. Why would your body burn your muscles (i.e. means of obtaining more food) when it's been storing stockpiles of energy in the form of fat? This right here, is a common myth.
There's only two tissues in your body that require glucose. Red blood cells and the brain. After 3 days 70% of the energy required by your brain is provided by ketones. The remaining glucose requirements are satisfied via gluconeogenesis from glycerol backbones of triglycerides, and yes, to a small extent, via protein breakdown. The entire rest of your energy requirements are satisfied via lipolysis, to the tune of 2/3 of a pound of fat per day. Or the equivalent of running 17 miles.
[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2405717/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2405717/
[2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10837292/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10837292/
[3] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3661473/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3661473/
[4] https://diabetes.diabetesjournals.org/content/50/1/96 https://diabetes.diabetesjournals.org/content/50/1/96