3 ms·
I think something missing here is that nearly all of the organizations that make use of buybacks do it because they have very seasonal or cyclical revenue. Airl
by legitster 6y ago
I think something missing here is that nearly all of the organizations that make use of buybacks do it because they have very seasonal or cyclical revenue. Airlines are a prime example - most of they time they are very unprofitable. It's easier to do buybacks one time than to turn dividends off and on again.
> But shareholders don’t benefit a great deal from all this paper revenue because shares are constantly being diluted by stock options granted to corporate executives, which were given a tax preference in 1981. The net benefit to shareholders is much less since much of the share buybacks simply offsets the dilution.
While I think the tax preference for stock options is probably misguided overall, this is clearly hyperbole, because we could see the dilution effect on the actual stock price. That is to say, if stock buybacks didn't actually raise the stock price... they wouldn't raise the stockprice? This logic doesn't really make sense.
This issue is also not mutually exclusive, and has nothing really to do with stock buybacks themselves.