13 ms·
> It's an enjoyable read, but in a similar vein as Harry Potter is an enjoyable read. Maybe it will provoke some thinking that's applicable to your work life, b
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
> It's an enjoyable read, but in a similar vein as Harry Potter is an enjoyable read. Maybe it will provoke some thinking that's applicable to your work life, but it's more entertaining than educational, IMO.
That's the unfortunate reality with a lot of Substack type newsletters.
The real world truth is often so boring and simple that it can be summarized in a short blog post. Want to get promoted? Work on important projects for the company, build rapport and relationships in the company, build a reputation for getting things done on time with high quality and low drama. You'll either get promoted, or build a foundation upon which you can pivot into a promotion at another company.
That's boring to read, though, so much pop-business advice turns into ego-stroking stories about how the reader is morally superior to all of the other unprincipled ladder-climbers around them. There's a large appetite for stories about how the world is unfair, and there are many writers happy to deliver those stories.
I'm part of a mentorship program for junior developers. These kinds of articles have been detrimental to a lot of impressionable young people who are growing up convinced that the world is thoroughly corrupt and therefore the only way to win is to become corrupt yourself. In reality, if anyone finds themselves at a company where people are promoted based on lies, nepotism, and general corruption then you don't want to get promoted there anyway. Get out while you can, because any company that rewards people who play games over people who deliver results is doomed to go downhill. In the real world, the good companies really do identify and promote those who consistently deliver results.
- borroka 6y agoThere are tech or tech-adjacent companies with tens of thousands of employees that have around for decades, when not 100+ years, who are corrupted in more than one meaning of the world. And they pay decently well, when not top 10%. I may have worked in one of those.
- Ericson2314 6y agoYou're a bit too optimistic. This article isn't saying "be evil or be out-hustled by evil", it's saying "avoid high growth companies because they are full of charlatans". Find a nice job at a small company growing organically.
- coffeemug 6y ago> Work on important projects for the company, build rapport and relationships in the company, build a reputation for getting things done on time with high quality and low drama. This will not get you promoted beyond the middle rungs.
- vikiomega9 6y agoYou'll need to say more :)
- ip26 6y agoThere's not a lot of room in the upper rungs. The audience of people trying to nab that promotion from VP to SVP at $FORTUNE500 is an awful small audience to write for.
- mertd 6y agoand the number of people who are actually qualified to dispatch such advice is even smaller.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThese pithy, cynical takes are devoid of any real claims or suggestions. What are you actually proposing as a way to the top rung? Gaming the system and being cutthroat?
- coffeemug 6y agoI am not proposing anything. I am just observing what happens empirically. Doing these things tends to get people soft influence but no formal authority. It's simply what is.
- beardedwizard 6y agoYou have never seen someone do good work, visibly, and be promoted for it?
- 6y ago
- BeetleB 6y agoNot to disagree with your overall criticism, but: > Want to get promoted? Work on important projects for the company, build rapport and relationships in the company, build a reputation for getting things done on time with high quality and low drama. You'll either get promoted, or build a foundation upon which you can pivot into a promotion at another company. Did you answer the question posed in the article: Which of the top leaders in your company get there by doing this? The only common theme seems to be "build rapport and relationships in the company".
- dennisgorelik 6y ago> These kinds of articles have been detrimental to a lot of impressionable young people This article is a satire, similar to Starship Troopers movie ~~~ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_Troopers_(film)#Critical_response https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_Troopers_(film)#Criti... "too damn well-made for its own good" and said that it confused audiences and critics. ~~~ Similarly, "How to get promoted" may be confusing. But you may also use these "tips" to identify [and fire] employees which try to abuse your corporate promotion system.