3 ms·
No they wouldn’t be. (Standard disclaimer I’m a consultant at AWS but far removed from the sales side). I’ve been a dev lead for a non software company. I was
by scarface74 6y ago
No they wouldn’t be. (Standard disclaimer I’m a consultant at AWS but far removed from the sales side).
I’ve been a dev lead for a non software company. I was trying to get training for my team on AWS. I had to go through all sorts of issues and approvals and POs and making sure that they are an approved vendor.
Then I just said forget it. AWS was already an approved vendor. I signed everyone up for an ACloudGuru account through the marketplace using the authority I already had.
I needed an intrusion detection and intrusion prevention system. Again, I just went to the marketplace and bought something through the marketplace.
You think it’s hard to get consumers to use third party app stores. You have never been through a corporate procurement process.
Besides the marketplaces basically let you search the AMIs that AWS offers alongside third party AMIs. No company is going to trust random third party marketplaces.
I assure that every company on the marketplace wants to be on the same bill as your AWS bill. Half the reason departments go to the cloud is to get away from the gate keepers. Once you get approval from the powers that be to use AWS, it’s much easier to buy off of the marketplace.
- jedberg 6y agoI've been through many corporate procurement processes, so I understand where you're coming from. But I disagree. First off, if Amazon couldn't offer their marketplace, if it were profitable, they would spin it off. Secondly, they would almost certainly work out a co-billing deal, where approved marketplaces could bill through AWS, because they too know about the value of being already approved. It would also be a way for them to keep making money off of a marketplace if they couldn't run one anymore. My point is, if AWS could not run their own marketplace, I'm sure solutions would come up to enable a 3rd party to work as smoothly as possible.
- scarface74 6y agoIf those marketplaces “billed” through Amazon what is the practical difference? Amazon still gets a cut and now you have two middlemen trying to make a profit. Also, wouldn’t AWS open itself up to more liability if it had no approval process for individual vendors? I thought the purpose of the internet was to reduce the number of middlemen?
- jedberg 6y agoIn this world, Amazon gets an equal cut whether you buy one of their offerings or a third party. It also starves them of competitive data.
- scarface74 6y agoHow would Amazon get an “equal cut”? Amazon makes money on using their infrastructure. So now are you going to also make AWS a dumb VPS and all of the 160+ services sold on top of it a separate business? You realize that there is tight integration between many of the services. So will it benefit consumers if they lose that type of integration? What about services that are not just “spin up an EC2 instance and pay for an AMI” like S3, Lambda, load balancers, etc? If supposedly technologically literate people on HN can’t think through all of the negative repercussions, how do you expect representatives in Congress - one of which grilled Zuckerberg over Twitter’s policies to do so? Why not just get rid of this whole capitalism thing and let the state run everything with “5 Year Plans”?