4 ms·
Some TikTok users are in the US, and taking a service away from them should happen under US law.
by whatshisface 6y ago
Some TikTok users are in the US, and taking a service away from them should happen under US law.
- Frost1x 6y agoI think the information age has really pushed the limits of what we find acceptable to leave to independent choice in democratic societies. Freedoms in democracy are being abused left-and-right to highlight specific weaknesses fundamental a democracy's healthy function. When it comes to TikTok, frankly I'm not sure if a foreign business under the thumb of the CCP is more or less a threat than businesses operating in our own country abusing the same freedoms for personal gain. You would assume those abusing the system located in the US had a vested interest in stability of the country for continuation of their lofty positions in society, but given broad anti-consumer and labor practices, both foreign and domestic are gutting the foundations of the social contract that make citizens want to believe in and support a democracy. I think the biggest blow we've had in this country is widespread undermining and exploitation of its citizens for personal gain, which have left many unable or in some cases, unwilling, to support the continuation of the system being used against them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bad_user 6y agoThe reverse of that coin is that abuse of freedom is turned into an excuse for restricting freedom. It's the modus operandi of authoritarianism.
- vin047 6y ago> frankly I'm not sure if a foreign business under the thumb of the CCP is more or less a threat than businesses operating in our own country abusing the same freedoms for personal gain. The difference is that a foreign business under the thumb of the CCP is essentially a CCP propagandist, capable of spreading pro-CCP, anti-US propaganda. US business's abusing US citizens are doing so purely for profit. This is bad and needs to be stopped, but IMO is the lesser of immediate concerns. Now of course the US government can (and indeed has) abused its own citizens for political manipulation too, via these tools. But the key difference is that the US government is (at least, in theory, and I agree more needs to be done here...) accountable to US citizens. The CCP is not. The CCP isn't even accountable to its own citizens, both in theory and in practice, which is exactly why many are against the CCP's modus operandi in the first place. > I think the information age has really pushed the limits of what we find acceptable to leave to independent choice in democratic societies. Freedoms in democracy are being abused left-and-right to highlight specific weaknesses fundamental a democracy's healthy function. This is precisely what the US's adversaries want; they want democracy to fail, because its failure strengthens their legitimacy as "the correct way" to govern, to any would-be naysayers.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thursday0987 6y agothats not how tariffs work, thats not how international trade works, and it has never worked that way. there is no right to any goods or services provided by a foreign entity. none. prove me wrong by providing a link to a law, treaty, or other official rule that says otherwise. i'll wait.
- whatshisface 6y agoLet's just think practically about what could happen. Suppose the chief executive has a grudge against an individual person. He or she bans them from owning anything produced overseas. Legal or not, I think we can agree that shouldn't be possible.
- vorpalhex 6y agoThat has nothing to do with the current case. You violate US law by spying on citizens, you get banned. As a foreign company you don't get a right to a trial. The US Government does not have a relationship with your users - you do. If you get banned, your users have a right to sue you to recoup their costs. The US Government does not owe your users anything. If you get banned from the supermarket for not wearing a mask, the supermarket doesn't owe anything to whoever you were making dinner for.
- whatshisface 6y ago>You violate US law by spying on citizens, you get banned. As a foreign company you don't get a right to a trial. If there's no trial, who is to say that any law was violated?
- vorpalhex 6y agoIt's literally a requirement of operating in China for the company to share that data with the CCP in full.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cooljacob204 6y agoWhy should it? Trading with other nations has never worked like that. No one has a right to a specific social media service, especially a foreign owned one at that.
- bduerst 6y agoThat goes against the first amendment.