2 ms·
Some people flag things that they think make them uncomfortable on partisan grounds on the basis that it is "political". It's not as prevalent as some people sa
by mhh__ 6y ago
Some people flag things that they think make them uncomfortable on partisan grounds on the basis that it is "political". It's not as prevalent as some people say it is but there is a subset of HN commenters who are very much in the "I'm alright jack"-camp of tacit trump supporters.
I can understand people who don't want political discussion but, I have two thoughts in response to that:
1. If you think is going to go down the drain, flag it after it happens not preemptively. HN is moderated, if it's that bad it'll get nuked.
2. When you have a president who is refusing to commit to leaving office if he loses the election, even after incident up incident of corruption who cares about the latest UI framework (I would say something JS-framework related but that's like shooting a fish in a barrel)
Billionaire president pays $750 in tax is almost guaranteed to be mentioned in every history of Trump - even poetically I think it transcends day to day politics enough to not be flagged.
- erik_seaberg 6y ago> HN is moderated, if it's that bad it'll get nuked. Political arguments attract users who are primarily interested in having political arguments (and who vastly outnumber us). That way lies Eternal September. > When you have [politics] who cares about the latest UI framework They have many explicitly political venues where this would be on topic. Why should it be impossible to maintain one venue in which it isn’t?
- mhh__ 6y ago> Why should it be impossible to maintain one venue in which it isn’t? I'm not saying it's an invalid viewpoint it just strikes me of the way that the producers/creative leads of the Call of Duty games call them "apolitical". If the flagging was more consistent I probably wouldn't have a problem with it but it seems that you're less likely to get downvoted/flagged with something contrarian.
- erik_seaberg 6y agoYeah, without any “you’re doing it wrong” feedback I don’t know how a community could agree to moderate in an even-handed way. I’m guessing people might have a “not this again” snap judgment about a mainstream story or ragebait they were already tired of seeing everywhere else.
- Nicksil 6y agoYou say this: >1. [...] flag it after it happens not preemptively. And then you say this: >2. When you have a president who is refusing to commit to leaving office if he loses the election, [...] The latter speaks of an event yet to occur. Using logic of the former, these discussions should take place after the latter has occurred.