3 ms·
Because a discussion of such an article is going to be almost pure politics, and almost certain to degenerate into a flamewar. That's not a good/worthwhile/use
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
Because a discussion of such an article is going to be almost pure politics, and almost certain to degenerate into a flamewar. That's not a good/worthwhile/useful discussion. (There's other places to do that; we don't need to do it on HN.)
- tertiary 6y agoThe fact that HN is set up to prevent flamewars and IMHO has been able to hold calm and reasoned discussion on politics in the past is all the more reason we should be talking about it here.
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago"A man's got to know his limitations." I respect HN's ability to have decent discussions. It's better than anywhere else I know of online. But I'm pretty sure that this one would degenerate, quickly and irreparably.
- mNovak 6y agoI understand the sentiment, but I wonder if ideally the appropriate action would be to moderate/flag the discussion itself, not the existence of the article. It seems unfortunate to ghost the article simply in anticipation of a poor discussion. Other contentious topics have been discussed on HN, and I for one would appreciate an objective HN-style discussion of the information presented
- marcinzm 6y agoThe article seems to be allowed now and basically every comment has negative votes. Doesn't matter which side of the fence it's on, everyone is nuking everyone else.
- ThrowawayR2 6y agoThere's only so many hours in the day for the moderators to read posts. Also, allowing political posts would attract those with a political axe to grind instead of hackers, making the problem worse. Please don't ask others to do what you wouldn't be willing to do yourself.
- just-juan-post 6y agoYep. Or, more accurately, there's nothing to be discussed but the superficial.